Optical detection of spin orbit torque and current induced heating

Yukihiro Marui,Masashi Kawaguchi,Masamitsu Hayashi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7567/APEX.11.093001

2018-11-17

Abstract:We have studied spin orbit torque in heavy metal (HM)/ferromagnetic metal (FM) bilayers using magneto-optical Kerr effect. A double modulation technique is developed to separate signals from spin orbit torque and Joule heating. At a current density of ~1x10$^{10}$ A/m$^2$, we observe optical signals that scale linearly and quadratically with the current density, both in similar magnitude. The spin orbit torque estimated using this technique is consistent with that evaluated using spin transport measurements. We find that changes in the refractive index of the film with temperature is the main source of the heating induced signal.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to separate the signals generated by the heating effects caused by spin - orbit torque and current in heavy - metal (HM)/ferromagnetic - metal (FM) bilayers by optical methods. Specifically, the authors developed a dual - modulation technique to distinguish these two signals and studied the magnitude of the spin - orbit torque at different current densities and its consistency with the transmission measurement results.

### Research Background

1. **Spin Orbit Torque**: Spin Orbit Torque (SOT) refers to the torque generated due to spin - orbit interaction, which can be used to control the magnetization direction in magnetic materials. This effect is particularly significant in bilayers composed of heavy metals (such as platinum Pt, tungsten W) and ferromagnetic metals (such as CoFeB).

2. **Current - Induced Heating**: When a large current passes through these materials, the Joule heating effect will occur, which may interfere with the experimental results, especially in optical measurements.

### Research Problems

The core problems of the paper are:
- How to separate the effects of spin - orbit torque and Joule heating effect in optical measurements?
- Verify the magnitude of spin - orbit torque through experiments and evaluate its consistency with the transmission measurement results.

### Solutions

The authors adopted a dual - modulation technique based on the Magneto - Optical Kerr Effect (MOKE). This method can effectively separate the signal that is linearly dependent on the current density (mainly from spin - orbit torque) and the signal that is quadratically dependent on the current density (mainly from Joule heating effect). The specific steps are as follows:

1. **Experimental Design**: Use a continuous - wave He - Ne laser (wavelength 633 nm, power 0.5 mW) to irradiate the sample, and detect the reflected light through a photoelastic modulator (PEM) and a polarization filter.

2. **Data Processing**: Extract two frequency components (`˜I1` and `I2`) by a lock - in amplifier, and analyze the data according to Fourier transform to obtain the change of Kerr ellipticity (η) with time.

3. **Signal Separation**: Decompose Kerr ellipticity into a linear term (`η1f`) and a quadratic term (`η2f`), where the linear term reflects the influence of spin - orbit torque, and the quadratic term is mainly caused by Joule heating effect.

4. **Result Analysis**: Calculate the effective field of spin - orbit torque (`hDL`) and the effective field of Joule heating effect (`hHE`) by fitting the experimental data, and compare them with the transmission measurement results.

### Main Findings

- When the current density is approximately \(1\times 10^{10}\, \text{A/m}^2\), the linear and quadratic signals have similar amplitudes.
- The efficiency of spin - orbit torque is consistent with the transmission measurement results.
- The optical signal caused by Joule heating effect mainly originates from the change of the refractive index of the thin film and the silicon oxide layer with temperature.

### Conclusion

This study successfully developed a dual - modulation technique that can effectively separate the signals of spin - orbit torque and Joule heating effect. This method not only improves the experimental accuracy but also provides a new approach for further research on spin - accumulation phenomena.