Estimation of spin-orbit torques in the presence of current-induced magnon creation and annihilation

Paul Noël,Emir Karadža,Richard Schlitz,Pol Welter,Charles-Henri Lambert,Luca Nessi,Federico Binda,Christian L. Degen,Pietro Gambardella

2024-11-13

Abstract:We present a comprehensive set of harmonic resistance measurements of the dampinglike (DL) and fieldlike (FL) torques in Pt/CoFeB, Pt/Co, W/CoFeB, W/Co, and YIG/Pt bilayers complemented by measurements of the DL torque using the magneto-optical Kerr effect and calibrated by nitrogen vacancy magnetometry on the same devices. The magnon creation-annihilation magnetoresistances depend strongly on temperature and on the magnetic and transport properties of each bilayer, affecting the estimate of both the DL and FL torque. The DL torque, the most important parameter for applications, is overestimated by a factor of 2 in W/CoFeB and by one order of magnitude in YIG/Pt when not accounting for the magnonic contribution to the planar Hall resistance. We further show that the magnonic contribution can be quantified by combining measurements of the nonlinear longitudinal and transverse magnetoresistances, thus providing a reliable method to measure the spin-orbit torques in different material systems.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to accurately estimate spin - orbit torques (SOTs) in the presence of current - induced magnon generation and annihilation. Specifically, the paper focuses on the measurement accuracy of damping - like (DL) and field - like (FL) torques in different material systems.

### Problem Background
Spin - orbit torques (SOTs) have important applications in new spintronic devices, such as high - speed, non - volatile, and durable storage and logic technologies. However, existing SOT measurement methods (such as harmonic Hall resistance measurement) may underestimate or overestimate the efficiency of SOTs in some cases, especially when current - induced magnon generation and annihilation are involved. This inaccuracy may lead to an incomplete understanding of the SOT physical mechanism, which in turn affects technology development.

### Core Problems of the Paper
1. **Limitations of Existing Measurement Methods**: Traditional harmonic Hall resistance analysis assumes that the magnetization is not affected by current and magnetic fields. However, in reality, magnon generation and annihilation caused by spin current will affect the magnetization, resulting in measurement result deviations.
2. **Non - linear Magnetoresistance Effect**: Magnon generation and annihilation will lead to transverse and longitudinal non - linear magnon - creation - annihilation magnetoresistances (m†mMRs). These effects have not been fully considered in previous studies, resulting in misestimation of DL and FL torques.
3. **Modified Measurement Method**: How to combine longitudinal and transverse second - harmonic resistance measurements to quantify m†mMRs and provide more accurate SOT estimates.

### Solutions
The paper proposes a comprehensive method to evaluate m†mMRs and SOT contributions by combining longitudinal and transverse second - harmonic resistance measurements. Specifically:
- **Revising the Estimation of DL and FL Torques**: Considering the influence of m†mMRs, the estimated values of DL and FL torques are revised.
- **Verifying the Effectiveness of the Method**: The effectiveness of the new method is verified by comparison with the calibrated magneto - optical Kerr effect (MOKE) technique.
- **Temperature - Dependence Study**: The existence of the magnon effect and its influence on SOT measurement are further confirmed through temperature - dependence experiments.

### Main Findings
- In the W/CoFeB and YIG/Pt bilayer structures, ignoring the magnon effect will cause the DL torque to be overestimated by a factor of 2 or even an order of magnitude.
- For the in - plane - magnetized NM/FM bilayer structure, m†mPHE (non - linear planar Hall effect) will lead to significant misestimation of DL and FL torques.
- Reducing the temperature can reduce the contribution of m†mMRs, which supports the influence of the magnon effect on SOT measurement.

In conclusion, this paper aims to improve the accuracy of DL and FL torque measurements in different material systems by introducing the concept of m†mMRs and modifying the existing SOT measurement methods.