Prediction of novel `magic' angles and correlations for twisted bilayer graphene in a perpendicular electric field

Steven C. Carter,Hridis K. Pal,M. Kindermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1810.13323

2018-10-31

Abstract:At certain angles of rotation called `magic angles' twisted bilayer graphene features almost flat bands. The resulting strong correlations drive the system to novel phases which have been observed in experiments recently. A complete understanding of the `magic' angle physics---both at the single-particle as well as the many-particle level---is still missing, and the search is ongoing. Here, we identify a new set of `magic' angles, where locally flat bands with a variety of possible many-body instabilities arise, but where the single-particle problem admits an exact solution. This occurs in the presence of an external perpendicular electric field at multicritical Lifshitz points. At these angles, which can be quantified exactly, the central band features a monkey saddle, resulting in strong electronic correlations.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Under the action of a vertical electric field, whether there are new "magic angles" in twisted bilayer graphene (TBG), and the influence of these angles on electron correlation.

### Specific problem description:

1. **Background of existing research**:
- When two layers of graphene are rotated relative to each other at a certain angle, moiré patterns will be formed, and this structure exhibits unique electronic properties.
- At some specific rotation angles (called "magic angles"), the system will have almost flat energy bands, resulting in strong electron correlation and thus novel physical states, such as Mott insulating state and superconducting state.
- Although there have been some studies on "magic angles", the understanding of its physical mechanism is still incomplete, especially at the single - particle and multi - particle levels.

2. **Core problems of the paper**:
- This paper aims to identify whether there are new "magic angles" in twisted bilayer graphene under the action of a vertical electric field. These new "magic angles" will not only lead to locally flat energy bands and strong correlation phenomena, but also at these angles, the single - particle problem can be accurately solved.
- The research found that at these new "magic angles", the central energy band exhibits a special geometric feature - "monkey saddle", which will lead to strong electron correlation.

### Main contributions of the paper:

- **Discovery of new "magic angles"**: Through theoretical calculations, the paper determined that there are new "magic angles" in twisted bilayer graphene under the action of a vertical electric field. These angles can be defined geometrically and are different from the known "magic angles".
- **Existence of accurate solutions**: At these new "magic angles", the single - particle Hamiltonian of the system can be accurately solved, which provides convenience for studying multi - body effects.
- **Experimental feasibility**: Since these new "magic angles" depend on the applied electric field, strong correlation phenomena can be observed in a wide range of rotation angles without extremely precise control of the rotation angle.

### Mathematical formula representation:

- **Hamiltonian form**:
\[
H=\begin{pmatrix}
0 & v(k_x - ik_y)e^{-i\frac{2\pi}{3}} & \Omega & \Omega \\
v(k_x + ik_y) & 0 & \Omega & \Omega \\
\Omega & \Omega & vk\cdot\hat{q}_1+\delta V & 0 \\
\Omega & \Omega & 0 & vk\cdot\hat{q}_2+\delta V \\
\Omega & \Omega & 0 & 0 & vk\cdot\hat{q}_3+\delta V
\end{pmatrix}
\]
where \(\Omega = \gamma\sqrt{\frac{1+\sqrt{3}}{2}}\), and \(\hat{q}_j\) represents the unit vector in the \(q_j\) direction.

- **Dispersion relation of "monkey saddle"**:
\[
\varepsilon=\frac{v^3}{12\Omega^2}(k_x^3 - 3\sqrt{3}k_x^2k_y - 3k_xk_y^2+\sqrt{3}k_y^3)
\]

### Summary:

This paper reveals new "magic angles" in twisted bilayer graphene by introducing a vertical electric field, and shows the energy band structure and electron correlation characteristics at these angles. These findings not only enrich the understanding of the "magic angle" phenomenon, but also provide a new approach for experimental research.