Abstract:The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction aims to prevent the abduction of children by their parents by ensuring the child's prompt return to his/her place of habitual residence. At the time of drafting the Convention, the drafters believed that non-custodial parents who were fathers perpetrated most of the abductions. However, the current statistics reveal the overwhelming majority of all abductors as primary or joint-primary caretakers. Unfortunately, it is unknown what exact proportion of these situations includes abductions triggered by domestic violence. In the absence of an explicit provision of domestic violence against spouses as a defence against an order of return, for a parent who has abducted a child to escape domestic violence, the relevant defence is of "grave risk of harm" to and "intolerable situation" for the child under Article 13(1)(b) of the Convention. However, the lack of guidance on what constitutes "grave risk" and "intolerable situation", at least in the past, and its operationalisation in the context of domestic violence brings in pervasive indeterminacy in child abduction. In 2012, the Hague Conference on Private International Law identified "domestic violence allegations and return proceedings" as a key issue and recommended steps for developing principles on the management of domestic violence allegations in return proceedings leading to the adoption of a Good Practice Guide on this issue in 2020.The Ministry of Women and Child Development (WCD) and the Ministry of Law and Justice, India, cite that most Indian parents who abduct their children happen to be women escaping domestic violence abroad. Thus, they are victims escaping for themselves and their children's safety. This research has summed up the judgments delivered by High Courts and the Supreme Court of India on child abduction between 1984 and 2019. Through judicial mapping, the paper discusses the cases in which battered women have highlighted and argued domestic violence as a reason against their children's return. The paper evaluates whether the reason given by the two ministries against India's accession to the Hague Convention is reflected in cases that have come up for judicial resolution and what are the criteria evolved by the judiciary in addressing the concerns of domestic violence against a spouse involved in child abduction. The paper analyses India's legislative initiative, the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction Bill, 2016 and assesses the measures proposed by the Bill for considering domestic violence against a spouse in abduction cases.

Crimes and misdemeanours: the case of child abandonment

Sex Offenses Against Minors In China: An Empirical Comparison

"Peculiar Finalities": Blurring the Borders between Abduction and Adoption?

A child-friendly area of freedom, security and justice: work in progress in international child abduction cases

Criminal Liability of Minors in Comparative Law: Special References to Japan and China. Implications

International Surrogacy Arrangements: Recent Developments and Ongoing Problems

A Re-Evaluation of the Role of Criminal law in Combating Parental Violence in the Netherlands

The age of criminal responsibility and juvenile justice in mainland China: a case study

The Rights of the Child at Risk

Child custody disputes within the context of child protection investigations: secondary analysis of the Canadian Incident Study of Reported Child Abuse and Neglect

Domestic violence and inter-country child abduction: an Indian judicial and legislative exploration

Abandonment in Danger, Resulting in the Death of the Victim: Problems of Theory and Judicial Practice

Article 11: The Right to Protection from Illicit Transfer and Non-return of Children Abroad

Physical child abuse and social change. Judicial intervention in families in The Netherlands, 1960-1995

Beyond the Life Sentence – A Children’s Rights Lens on Sentencing for Murder

Kevin and Peter: responses to two ‘preventable deaths’

Accommodations of private and family life and non-traditional families: the limits of deference in cases of cross-border surrogacy before the European Court of Human Rights

Child-Friendly Justice: turning law into reality

The thin line between protection and conviction: Experiences with child protection services and later criminal convictions among a population of adolescents

The legally charged issue of cross-border surrogacy: Current regulatory challenges and future prospects

[Admission with freedom restriction of minors to child and adolescent psychiatrics clinics--medical decisions without regard for psychodynamic sequelae?]