Abstract:Background: Clinical narratives represent the main form of communication within health care, providing a personalized account of patient history and assessments, and offering rich information for clinical decision making. Natural language processing (NLP) has repeatedly demonstrated its feasibility to unlock evidence buried in clinical narratives. Machine learning can facilitate rapid development of NLP tools by leveraging large amounts of text data. Objective: The main aim of this study was to provide systematic evidence on the properties of text data used to train machine learning approaches to clinical NLP. We also investigated the types of NLP tasks that have been supported by machine learning and how they can be applied in clinical practice. Methods: Our methodology was based on the guidelines for performing systematic reviews. In August 2018, we used PubMed, a multifaceted interface, to perform a literature search against MEDLINE. We identified 110 relevant studies and extracted information about text data used to support machine learning, NLP tasks supported, and their clinical applications. The data properties considered included their size, provenance, collection methods, annotation, and any relevant statistics. Results: The majority of datasets used to train machine learning models included only hundreds or thousands of documents. Only 10 studies used tens of thousands of documents, with a handful of studies utilizing more. Relatively small datasets were utilized for training even when much larger datasets were available. The main reason for such poor data utilization is the annotation bottleneck faced by supervised machine learning algorithms. Active learning was explored to iteratively sample a subset of data for manual annotation as a strategy for minimizing the annotation effort while maximizing the predictive performance of the model. Supervised learning was successfully used where clinical codes integrated with free-text notes into electronic health records were utilized as class labels. Similarly, distant supervision was used to utilize an existing knowledge base to automatically annotate raw text. Where manual annotation was unavoidable, crowdsourcing was explored, but it remains unsuitable because of the sensitive nature of data considered. Besides the small volume, training data were typically sourced from a small number of institutions, thus offering no hard evidence about the transferability of machine learning models. The majority of studies focused on text classification. Most commonly, the classification results were used to support phenotyping, prognosis, care improvement, resource management, and surveillance. Conclusions: We identified the data annotation bottleneck as one of the key obstacles to machine learning approaches in clinical NLP. Active learning and distant supervision were explored as a way of saving the annotation efforts. Future research in this field would benefit from alternatives such as data augmentation and transfer learning, or unsupervised learning, which do not require data annotation.

Machine Learning for Structured Clinical Data

Applying Machine Learning Approaches to Suicide Prediction Using Healthcare Data: Overview and Future Directions

A Review of Challenges and Opportunities in Machine Learning for Health

Machine learning in healthcare -- a system's perspective

Clinical Applications of Machine Learning

Machine Learning and Visualization in Clinical Decision Support: Current State and Future Directions

Machine Learning for Clinical Data Processing

Deep EHR: A Survey of Recent Advances in Deep Learning Techniques for Electronic Health Record (EHR) Analysis

Can structured EHR data support clinical coding? A data mining approach

Strategies for Implementing Machine Learning Algorithms in the Clinical Practice of Radiology

From Real‐World Patient Data to Individualized Treatment Effects Using Machine Learning: Current and Future Methods to Address Underlying Challenges

Machine Learning for Clinical Decision-Making: Challenges and Opportunities in Cardiovascular Imaging

Machine learning and artificial intelligence: applications in healthcare epidemiology

Machine Learning Applied to Routinely Collected Health Administrative Data

Clinical Text Data in Machine Learning: Systematic Review

Machine Learning for Administrative Health Records: A Systematic Review of Techniques and Applications

A survey of machine learning techniques in medical applications

Big data and machine learning algorithms for health-care delivery

Data Mining and Electronic Health Records: Selecting Optimal Clinical Treatments in Practice

Using Deep Learning Based Natural Language Processing Techniques for Clinical Decision-Making with EHRs

The Dependence of Machine Learning on Electronic Medical Record Quality