Abstract:People experience instances of social feedback as interdependent with potential implications for their entire self-concept. How do people maintain positivity and coherence across the self-concept while updating self-views from feedback? We present a network model describing how the brain represents the semantic dependency relations among traits and uses this information to avoid an overall loss of positivity and coherence. Both male and female human participants received social feedback during a self-evaluation task while undergoing functional magnetic resonance imaging. We modeled self-belief updating by incorporating a reinforcement learning model within the network structure. Participants learned more rapidly from positive than negative feedback and were less likely to change self-views for traits with more dependencies in the network. Further, participants back propagated feedback across network relations while retrieving prior feedback on the basis of network similarity to inform ongoing self-views. Activation in ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) reflected the constrained updating process such that positive feedback led to higher activation and negative feedback to less activation for traits with more dependencies. Additionally, vmPFC was associated with the novelty of a trait relative to previously self-evaluated traits in the network, and angular gyrus was associated with greater certainty for self-beliefs given the relevance of prior feedback. We propose that neural computations that selectively enhance or attenuate social feedback and retrieve past relevant experiences to guide ongoing self-evaluations may support an overall positive and coherent self-concept. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT We humans experience social feedback throughout our lives, but we do not dispassionately incorporate feedback into our self-concept. The implications of feedback for our entire self-concept plays a role in how we either change or retain our prior self-beliefs. In a neuroimaging study, we find that people are less likely to change their beliefs from feedback when the feedback has broader implications for the self-concept. This resistance to change is reflected in processing in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, a region that is central to self-referential and social cognition. These results are broadly applicable given the role that maintaining a positive and coherent self-concept plays in promoting mental health and development throughout the lifespan.

The effects of feedback self-consistency, therapist status, and attitude toward therapy on reaction to personality feedback

Therapist verification of patient self-concepts as a responsive precondition for early alliance development and subsequent introject change

The Trouble with Change: Self-Verification and Allegiance to the Self

Says Who? Credibility Effects in Self-Verification Strivings

Self-verification in clinical depression: The desire for negative evaluation.

Self-Liking, Self-Competence, and the Quest for Self-Verification

The Effects of Self-esteem on the Tendency Towards Self-verification: Evidences from Choosing Interaction Partners

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

An examination of therapists' professional characteristics as moderators of the effect of feedback on psychological treatment outcomes

Allure of negative feedback: Self-verification strivings among depressed persons.

Effects of therapist response modes in brief psychotherapy.

Compromises produced by the dialectic between self-verification and self-enhancement

Adapting psychotherapy to patient reactance level: A meta-analytic review

Depression and the search for negative evaluations: More evidence of the role of self-verification strivings.

Depression and selection of positive and negative social feedback: motivated preference or cognitive balance?

Identity Shift Effects of Self-Presentation and Confirmatory and Disconfirmatory Feedback on Self-Perceptions of Brand Identification

Social anxiety and the ironic effects of positive interviewer feedback

A Fluid Self-Concept: How the Brain Maintains Coherence and Positivity across an Interconnected Self-Concept While Incorporating Social Feedback

Is identity per se irrelevant? A contrarian view of self-verification effects

The differential effect of psychotherapy and psychoanalysis with anaclitic and introjective patients: the Menninger Psychotherapy Research Project revisited

Changes in depressed patients’ self-statements