Abstract:Purpose Brand identities have a dual nature that appeals to the head (rational appeal) and to the heart (emotional appeal) of their consumers. Furthermore, consumers can process information in a predominately analytic or intuitive cognitive style (CS) manner. This study aims to analyze the influence of brand identity-cognitive style (BI-CS) fit on the perceived value of a brand. It also analyzes how different forms of social influence affect the perceived value of the brand. Design/methodology/approach Using a two-step experimental design, Step 1 examines the effect that BI-CS fit has on consumer-based brand equity (CBBE); Step 2 evaluates the effect that the three elements of social influence–compliance, identification and internalization–have on CBBE. Findings Both the BI-CS fit, and the identification and internalization forms of social influence have a significant and positive effect over the perceived value of the brand. A rational brand identity is given a higher perceived brand value by analytic CS consumers than intuitive CS consumers. Conversely, an emotional brand identity is given a higher perceived brand value by intuitive CS consumers than analytic CS consumers. However, whether the brand identity is more emotional or rational is less important than the values and beliefs that the brand communicates to create social influence. Research limitations/implications This study contributes to the branding literature by introducing the CS concept to better understand the influence of emotional and rational brand identities on consumers with either rational or intuitive cognitive thinking styles and reinforce the importance of the brand duality concept. Practical implications The results demonstrate the importance of brand duality and show how firms could present emotional or rational brand identities depending on their consumers’ CS to increase the effectiveness of their messaging to build stronger brand images that increase the perceived value of the brand. These findings could have important implications for market segmentation. Originality/value Brand identities can be emotional or rational, and this creates more or less value depending on the consumers’ CS, but what is more important is that consumers internalize the brand’s message or identify with what the brand represents. Although this has been discussed in prior literature, the original contribution of this paper is tying all these concepts together.

Identity Shift Effects of Self-Presentation and Confirmatory and Disconfirmatory Feedback on Self-Perceptions of Brand Identification

Self-Presentation on Social Media: When Self-Enhancement Confronts Self-Verification

Collaboration between East and West: influence of consumer dialectical self on attitude towards co-brand personality traits

The impact of advertising self-presentation style on customer purchase intention

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

Make a Good Impression: Recommend Different Products for Self-Presentation

Influencer marketing: explaining the effects of influencer self-presentation strategies on brand responses through source credibility

Who Do You Think You Are? Common and Differential Effects of Social Self-Identity on Social Media Usage

Pride or empathy? Exploring effective CSR communication strategies on social media

Self-Presentation in Social Media: Review and Research Opportunities

A snap of your true self: How self-presentation and temporal affordance influence self-concept on social media

The retail brand personality—Behavioral outcomes framework: Applications to identity and social identity theories

Self-construal on brand fan pages: the mediating effect of para-social interaction and consumer engagement on brand loyalty

The effect of brand identity-cognitive style fit and social influence on consumer-based brand equity

Affective compatibility with the self modulates the self-prioritisation effect

Self-esteem discrepancies and identity-expressive consumption: Evidence from Norwegian adolescents

Like, Comment, or Share? Self-presentation vs. brand relationships as drivers of social media engagement choices

Self-presentation and interactivity: luxury branding on social media

Self-Concept Clarity and Online Self-Presentation in Adolescents

How Do Face Consciousness and Public Self-Consciousness Affect Consumer Decision-Making?