First-order quantum phase transition in three-dimensional topological band insulators

Vladimir Juricic,D. S. L. Abergel,A. V. Balatsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.95.161403

2016-12-09

Abstract:Topological states of matter are characterized by global topological invariants which change their value across a topological quantum phase transition. It is commonly assumed that the transition between topologically distinct noninteracting gapped phases of fermions is necessarily accompanied by the closing of the band gap as long as the symmetries of the system are maintained. We show that such a quantum phase transition is possible without closing the gap in the case of a three-dimensional topological band insulator. We demonstrate this by calculating the free energy of the minimal model for a topological insulator, the Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model, and show that as the band curvature continuously varies, a jump between the band gap minima corresponding to the topologically trivial and nontrivial insulators occurs. Therefore, this first order phase transition is a generic feature of three-dimensional topological band insulators. For a certain parameter range we predict a re-entrant topological phase transition. We discuss our findings in connection with the recent experimental observation of a discontinuous topological phase transition in a family of topological crystalline insulators.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the question of whether there exists a first-order quantum phase transition (i.e., a discontinuous topological quantum phase transition) in three-dimensional topological insulators that does not accompany a gap closing. The conventional view holds that the transition between a topologically nontrivial phase and a topologically trivial phase must be accompanied by a gap closing, which is a continuous (second-order) phase transition. However, recent experiments have observed discontinuous phase transitions in certain topological crystalline insulators. Therefore, this paper aims to explore whether such discontinuous topological quantum phase transitions can be explained within a non-interacting theoretical framework.

Specifically, the authors demonstrate by calculating the free energy of the Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang (BHZ) model that under certain conditions, with the continuous change of band curvature, the global minimum of the free energy can undergo a sudden change, leading to a discontinuous transition between the topologically trivial phase and the topologically nontrivial phase. Additionally, the authors discuss the impact of temperature on this phase transition and predict the possibility of a re-entrant phase transition within certain parameter ranges, where the system transitions from a topologically nontrivial phase to a topologically trivial phase and then back to a topologically nontrivial phase as the temperature increases.

In summary, the main objective of this paper is to verify and explain whether there exists a first-order quantum phase transition in three-dimensional topological insulators that does not accompany a gap closing, and to explore its physical mechanism.