Abstract:Social decision schemes (SDSs) map the preferences of a group of voters over some set of m alternatives to a probability distribution over the alternatives. A seminal characterization of strategyproof SDSs by Gibbard (Econometrica 45(3):665–681, 1977) implies that there are no strategyproof Condorcet extensions and that only random dictatorships satisfy ex post efficiency and strategyproofness. The latter is known as the random dictatorship theorem . We relax Condorcet-consistency and ex post efficiency by introducing a lower bound on the probability of Condorcet winners and an upper bound on the probability of Pareto-dominated alternatives, respectively. We then show that the randomized Copeland rule is the only anonymous, neutral, and strategyproof SDS that guarantees the Condorcet winner a probability of at least 2/ m . Secondly, we prove a continuous strengthening of Gibbard's random dictatorship theorem: the less probability we put on Pareto-dominated alternatives, the closer to a random dictatorship is the resulting SDS. Finally, we show that the only anonymous, neutral, and strategyproof SDSs that maximize the probability of Condorcet winners while minimizing the probability of Pareto-dominated alternatives are mixtures of the uniform random dictatorship and the randomized Copeland rule.

The Borda and Condorcet winners coincide for lexicographic preferences

Condorcet-loser dominance between the plurality rule and other scoring rules

The Condorcet Dimension of Metric Spaces

On the reversal bias of the Minimax social choice correspondence

Plurality rule and Condorcet criterion over restricted domains

Condorcet Consistency And Pairwise Justifiability Under Variable Agendas

From Condorcet's paradox to Arrow: yet another simple proof of the impossibility theorem

Semi-Random Impossibilities of Condorcet Criterion

A polarity theory for sets of desirable gambles

A generalization to networks of Young's characterization of the Borda rule

Condorcet-Consistent Choice Among Three Candidates

Strong core and Pareto-optimality in the multiple partners matching problem under lexicographic preference domains

Local Diversity of Condorcet Domains

Wine rankings and the Borda method

Relaxed notions of Condorcet-consistency and efficiency for strategyproof social decision schemes

Incentives in Social Decision Schemes with Pairwise Comparison Preferences

Resolute refinements of social choice correspondences

Une remarque à propos de l'équivalence bilipschitzienne entre des ensembles de Delone. (A remark concerning bi-Lipschitz equivalence between Delone sets.)

Conical geodesic bicombings on subsets of normed vector spaces

Balancedness of Social Choice Correspondences

Noncommutative Poisson vertex algebras and Courant-Dorfman algebras