Abstract:Self-organized spatial patterns of vegetation are frequent in drylands and, because pattern shape correlates with water availability, they have been suggested as important indicators of ecosystem health. However, the mechanisms underlying pattern emergence remain unclear. Some theories hypothesize that patterns could result from a water-mediated scale-dependent feedback (SDF) whereby interactions favoring plant growth dominate at short distances and growth–inhibitory interactions dominate in the long range. However, we know little about how the presence of a focal plant affects the fitness of its neighbors as a function of the inter-individual distance, which is expected to be highly ecosystem-dependent. This lack of empirical knowledge and system dependency challenge the relevance of SDF as a unifying theory for vegetation pattern formation. Assuming that plant interactions are always inhibitory and only their intensity is scale-dependent, alternative theories also recover the typical vegetation patterns observed in nature. Importantly, although these alternative hypotheses lead to visually indistinguishable patterns, they predict contrasting desertification dynamics, which questions the potential use of vegetation patterns as ecosystem-state indicators. To help resolve this issue, we first review existing theories for vegetation self-organization and their conflicting predictions about desertification dynamics. Second, we discuss potential empirical tests via manipulative experiments to identify pattern-forming mechanisms and link them to specific desertification dynamics. A comprehensive view of models, the mechanisms they intend to capture, and experiments to test them in the field will help to better understand both how patterns emerge and improve predictions on the fate of the ecosystems where they form.

A pattern-forming instability co-driven by distinct mechanisms increases pattern diversity

Regime shifts in models of dryland vegetation

Vegetation Pattern Formation of a Water-Biomass Model.

Turing Instabilities are Not Enough to Ensure Pattern Formation

Ecosystems with mutually exclusive interactions self-organize to a state of high diversity

Diversity Begets Stability in an Evolving Network

Intraspecific competition in models for vegetation patterns: Decrease in resilience to aridity and facilitation of species coexistence

Phenotypic plasticity: A missing element in the theory of vegetation pattern formation

The inherent multidimensionality of temporal variability: How common and rare species shape stability patterns

Metastability as a coexistence mechanism in a model for dryland vegetation patterns

Diversity begets stability: Sublinear growth and competitive coexistence across ecosystems

Spatial dynamics of a vegetation model in an arid flat environment

Localised pattern formation in a model for dryland vegetation

A universal route to pattern formation

Stability and cross-diffusion-driven instability for a water-vegetation model with the infiltration feedback effect

Pattern formation and global analysis of a systematically reduced plant model in dryland environment

Different Mechanisms of Pattern Formation in a Plankton Model with Cross-Diffusion and Fitness

Control of diffusion-driven pattern formation behind a wave of competency

Pattern Formation in Mesic Savannas

Integrating theory and experiments to link local mechanisms and ecosystem-level consequences of vegetation patterns in drylands