Abstract:There have been over 17 million COVID-19 infections worldwide up to July 31, 2020, but the exact transmission route remains a subject for debate. Virus load in different-sized respiratory droplets is the key to address the above question. Investigation on the droplet deposition characteristics during exhalation inside the respiratory tract will facilitate the understanding of their origin and importance in transmitting the respiratory infection. Based on a realistic respiratory model, this study utilized the computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulation to investigate the deposition of droplets originating from infection sites like pharynx, larynx and trachea under three flow conditions, namely 30 L/min (representing the normal breathing condition), 60 L/min (speaking) and 180 L/min (coughing). The SST k-omega turbulence model integrated in ANSYS Fluent software was utilized to obtain the flow field inside the respiratory tract by solving the continuity and momentum equations, and the Lagrangian approach was used to calculate droplet motion and deposition with the discrete random walk model to account for the turbulence fluctuation effect. Evaporation of droplets was not considered inside the saturated respiratory tract. Droplet diameter, flow rate of the exhaling air, and complexity of the respiratory tract geometry are the most important factors in determining the deposition pattern of respiratory droplets. It is revealed that the largest droplet that originates from the joint of pharynx and larynx and is able to escape out of the respiratory tract is about 20 mu m (30 L/min) or 10 mu m (60-180 L/min) in diameter; the so-called cut-off sizes for vocal cord and trachea originated droplets are 7 mu m (30 L/min), 5 mu m (60 L/min) or 3 mu m (180 L/min). Larynx and joint of larynx and pharynx are the most important deposition sites due to their complexity in geometry and the existence of the laryngeal jet, whose velocity is up to 102 m/s during coughing and 32 m/s during speaking; the nasal cavity is also effective in trapping relatively small droplets as the airflow has a sudden change in direction before entering the oral cavity. Under the investigated speaking scenario (60 L/min), the escape rate of 1 mu m droplets is around 50%, and the maximum escape rates of 5 and 10 mu m droplets are respectively 13.1% and 1.3% (originating from the joint of pharynx and larynx). Although large droplets up to several hundred micrometers can be produced inside the oral cavity due to the atomization mechanism, they seldom carry pathogen. Thus, for COVID-19 patents in the early stage of infection who show upper respiratory symptoms, the cut-off size of virus-laden droplets released into the environment is about 20 mu m; with the shifting of infection to the lower respiratory tract in the later stage, the cut-off size decreases to 7 mu m. Respiratory droplets evaporate immediately after escaping into the indoor environments and shrink to about one third of their initial size, so airborne route is speculated to be important in the transmission of COVID-19. Further investigations considering realistic flow conditions together with droplet sampling experiments on human volunteers are necessary to confirm these cut-off sizes.

Beyond droplet deposition: Virus transport and deposition modeling in respiratory tract influenced by ambient environment and exhalation activities

Numerical Investigation on the Origin of Virus-Laden Droplets in the Respiratory Tract

Deposition of Droplets from the Trachea or Bronchus in the Respiratory Tract During Exhalation: A Steady-State Numerical Investigation

Modeling the load of SARS-CoV-2 virus in human expelled particles during coughing and speaking

Deposition features of inhaled viral droplets may lead to rapid secondary transmission of COVID-19

Safe Distance of Virus Quantitative Analysis and Simulation of the Trajectory of Pathogen-Containing Droplets in the Air Respiratory Airways

What Sizes of Droplets Contribute to Long-Range Airborne Transmission?

Investigation on the evaporation and dispersion of human respiratory droplets with COVID-19 virus

How Far Droplets Can Move In Indoor Environments - Revisiting The Wells Evaporation-Falling Curve

Predominance of Inhalation Route in Short-Range Transmission of Respiratory Viruses: Investigation Based on Computational Fluid Dynamics

Numerical simulation on exhaled aerosol transmission based on realistic oral-nasal structures and temperature distribution

Prediction of transmission routes of respiratory infectious diseases in indoor environment: Based on droplet evaporation and sedimentation analysis

Short-range exposure to airborne virus transmission and current guidelines

Modeling and experimental study of dispersion and deposition of respiratory emissions with implications for disease transmission

Lung aerosol dynamics of airborne influenza A virus-laden droplets and the resultant immune system responses: An in silico study

Numerical study of the transport of droplets or particles generated by respiratory system indoors

Airborne dispersion of droplets during coughing: a physical model of viral transmission

Challenges in simulating and modeling the airborne virus transmission: A state-of-the-art review

Analyzing the dominant SARS-CoV-2 transmission routes toward an ab initio disease spread model

Effects of occupant behavior and ventilation on exposure to respiratory droplets in the indoor environment

Quantifying human and environmental viral load relationships amidst mitigation strategies in a controlled chamber with participants having COVID-19