W. G. Unruh
Abstract:The slinky, released from rest hanging under its own weight, falls in a peculiar manner. The bottom stays at rest until a wave hits it from above. Two cases -- one unphysical one where the slinky is able to pass through itself, and the other where the coils of the slinky collide creating a shock wave travelling down the slinky -- are analysed. In the former case, the bottom begins to move much later than in the latter.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How can the motion behavior be described when a vertically suspended Slinky freely falls under its own gravity? In particular, why does the bottom of the spring remain stationary for a period of time, and how can the dynamic process of the entire spring be analyzed?**
### Core problem decomposition of the paper:
1. **Dynamical behavior of the falling spring**:
- When a vertically suspended spring is released, its bottom will experience a "delay", that is, it remains stationary for a period of time until the wave front propagates from the top to the bottom.
- What is the reason for this phenomenon? How can it be described by a mathematical model?
2. **Analysis of two situations**:
- **Ideal situation**: Assuming that the coils of the spring can penetrate each other (not a physical actual situation), what is the behavior of the spring at this time?
- **Actual collision situation**: Considering the situation where irreversible collisions occur between the spring coils, a shock wave will be generated at this time. How can the propagation of this shock wave be analyzed?
3. **Energy conservation and dissipation**:
- What is the change law of the total energy during the falling process of the spring?
- Will the energy dissipation caused by the shock wave affect the overall dynamics of the system?
---
### Specific analysis:
#### 1. Ideal behavior of the spring
The paper first analyzes the motion of the spring in an ideal situation. By using the Lagrangian mechanics method, the author derives the motion equation of the spring and gives the analytical solution under the initial and boundary conditions.
- **Motion equation**:
$$
\rho \frac{\partial^2 x}{\partial t^2} - k \frac{\partial^2 x}{\partial y^2} + \rho g = 0
$$
where:
- $\rho$ is the mass density of the spring,
- $k$ is the elastic coefficient of the spring,
- $g$ is the acceleration due to gravity,
- $x(t, y)$ is the position of the point with coordinate $y$ on the spring at time $t$.
- **Initial conditions**:
- The spring is stationary at the initial moment: $\frac{\partial x}{\partial t}\big|_{t = 0}=0$.
- The initial shape is determined by the gravity balance: $x(y)=\frac{1}{2}\frac{\rho g}{k}y^2$.
- **Boundary conditions**:
- There is no external force acting on both ends of the spring: $\frac{\partial x}{\partial y}\big|_{y = 0}=\frac{\partial x}{\partial y}\big|_{y = L}=0$.
By solving the above equation, the author finds that the bottom of the spring remains stationary for a period of time until the wave front propagates from the top to the bottom.
---
#### 2. Actual collision situation
In the actual situation, irreversible collisions will occur between the spring coils, forming a shock wave. The paper analyzes the behavior of this shock wave through the conservation of momentum and energy.
- **Velocity of the shock wave**:
The velocity of the shock wave is greater than the speed of sound $v$ in the spring, and as the shock wave approaches the bottom of the spring, its velocity gradually decreases.
- **Energy change**:
- The total energy gradually decreases during the propagation of the shock wave. The main reason is that the mechanical energy is converted into heat energy due to the coil collisions.
- The energy loss does not occur linearly, but reaches the maximum rate when the shock wave approaches the bottom of the spring.
---
#### 3. Summary of mathematical results
- **Position function in the ideal situation**:
$$
x(t, y)=-\frac{1}{2}gt^2 + f(y + vt)+h(y - vt)
$$
where $f$ and $h$ are functions that satisfy specific boundary conditions.
- **Energy expression in the actual collision situation**:
$$
E=\rho\frac{g^2}{6v^2}L^3(L^3 + L^2Y + LY^2 - Y^3)
$$
indicating that the total energy gradually decreases over time.
---