Outsourcing Competence

J.A. Bergstra,G.P.A.J. Delen,S.F.M. van Vlijmen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1109.6536

2011-09-29

Abstract:The topic of this paper, competences needed for outsourcing, is organized by first providing a generic competence scheme, which is subsequently instantiated to the area of sourcing and outsourcing. Sourcing and outsourcing are positioned as different areas of activity, neither one of which is subsumed under the other one. It is argued that competences relevant for outsourcing are mainly community based rather than evidence based. Subjective ability and objective ability are distinguished as categories, together making up ability, which are distinct but not necessarily disjoint from competence. Conjectural ability is introduced as a form of subjective ability. A person's competence profile includes competences as well as abilities, including subjective ones. Competence assessment and acquisition as well as the impact of assessed competence on practical work is described. The analysis of competence and ability thus developed is used as standpoint from which to extract a specification of an audience for a theory of outsourcing, yet to be written. Moreover, it allows to formulate requirements for and in preparation of the development of an outsourcing theory. Formulating these requirements is done under the assumption that a person's awareness of a theory of outsourcing is expected to strengthen that person's outsourcing competence profile.

Other Computer Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:

1. **Definition and Understanding of Outsourcing Competence**: The paper explores how to define and understand outsourcing competence, especially in the absence of a sufficient evidence base. The author believes that it is currently infeasible to provide a reliable evidence base in the field of outsourcing, so a concept of competence that does not rely on an evidence base is required.

2. **Distinguishing Outsourcing from Insourcing**: The paper emphasizes the importance of distinguishing outsourcing from insourcing. Although these two concepts are often used interchangeably, the author believes that they represent different types of activities and should not substitute for each other.

3. **Differences between Ability and Competence**: The paper proposes the differences between ability and competence and introduces the concept of conjectural ability. Conjectural ability refers to an assumption made by a community or a small group about the possible abilities of certain individuals or organizations in the absence of sufficient evidence support.

4. **Impact of Theory on Practice**: The paper discusses how to enhance an individual's outsourcing competence by developing outsourcing theory. The author believes that the understanding of outsourcing theory can strengthen an individual's outsourcing competence, but the development of such theory needs to be based on an in - depth analysis of existing competence and requirements.

5. **Requirements for Outsourcing Theory**: The paper proposes specific requirements for outsourcing theory, which are aimed at ensuring that the theory can effectively enhance an individual's outsourcing competence. The author believes that the development of theory should be a systematic top - down process while remaining open to adapt to future development directions.

### Analysis of Specific Problems

1. **Definition of Outsourcing Competence**:
- **Differences between Ability and Competence**: The paper points out that ability refers to the ability to effectively complete tasks in a specific situation, while competence refers to the means recognized by others to achieve a certain goal. In the absence of an evidence base, ability can exist independently of competence.
- **Conjectural Ability**: Conjectural ability is a subjective form of ability, which may exist in a certain community or small group even without sufficient evidence support.

2. **Distinguishing Outsourcing from Insourcing**:
- **Types of Activities**: Outsourcing and insourcing are different types of activities. The former refers to transferring certain business activities to external organizations, while the latter refers to retaining these activities within internal organizations.
- **Perspective**: From the perspective of a specific unit, both outsourcing and insourcing are resource allocation and management activities carried out to meet the functional requirements of the unit.

3. **Impact of Theory on Practice**:
- **Development of Theory**: The paper believes that developing outsourcing theory requires a systematic approach, starting from high - level requirements and gradually refining them into specific practical requirements.
- **Enhancement of Competence**: The understanding of outsourcing theory can enhance an individual's outsourcing competence, but this enhancement needs to be based on an in - depth analysis of existing competence and requirements.

4. **Requirements for Outsourcing Theory**:
- **Systematicness**: The development of theory should be systematic, starting from high - level requirements and gradually refining them into specific practical requirements.
- **Openness**: The development of theory should remain open to adapt to future development directions and new practical requirements.

Through the discussion of these problems, the paper aims to provide clear requirements and guidance for the development of outsourcing theory, thereby enhancing the practical competence of individuals and organizations in the outsourcing field.