Barriers and Facilitators for Female Healthcare Professionals to Be Leaders in Pakistan: A Qualitative Exploratory Study
Sundus Iftikhar,Rahila Yasmeen,Rehan Ahmed Khan,Mahwish Arooj
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/JHL.S399430
2023-06-01
Journal of Healthcare Leadership
Abstract:Sundus Iftikhar, 1 Rahila Yasmeen, 2 Rehan Ahmed Khan, 2 Mahwish Arooj 1 1 University College of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Lahore, Lahore, PB, Pakistan; 2 Islamic International Medical College, Riphah International University, Rawalpindi, PB, Pakistan Correspondence: Sundus Iftikhar, 26-C extension DHA Phase 8 ex-Parkview, Lahore, Pakistan, Tel +923457363111, Email Purpose: Despite being in high numbers in medical colleges, only a small proportion of women join the workforce and even fewer reach leadership positions in Pakistan. Organizations like United Nations and Women Global Health are working towards closing the gender gap. The study aims to explore the enablers and barriers for women in healthcare leadership and to explore the strategies to promote women in leadership positions in Pakistan's specific societal culture. Methods: In this qualitative exploratory study, semi-structured interviews of 16 women holding leadership positions in the health-care profession, ie, medical and dental (basic or clinical sciences) were included. The data were collected until saturation was achieved. The data were analyzed in MS Excel. Deductive and Inductive thematic analysis was done. Results: Thirty-eight codes were generated that were combined in the form of categories. The major themes that emerged from the data were: elevating factors, the shackles holding them back, let us bring them up and implicit bias. Elevating factors were intrinsic motivation and exceptional qualifications, while the shackles were related to gender bias, male insecurities, and lack of political background. It was noteworthy that differences in gender roles were highly defined by culture and religion. Conclusion: There is a need to change the perception of South Asian society and redefine gender roles through media and individual attempts. Women must take charge of their choices and believe in themselves. The institutional policies to help promote gender equality would be mentorship programs for new faculty, gender-responsive training for everyone, equal opportunities for all, and maintaining gender diversity on all committees. Keywords: gender disparity, leadership in the health profession, gender roles in Pakistani society The number of female doctors around the world has increased in the last 50 years. For example, the percentage of women in medical schools in America has risen from 11.1% in 1970 to 47.8% by 2001 and from 25% in 1970 to a little over 50% by 2015 in Australia. 1,2 Nowadays, girls are higher achievers than boys academically, and girls also make up 56% of students in A level taking biological sciences. 3 This trend is not different in developing countries like India and Pakistan where it has been noted that nearly 70% of students in medical colleges comprise females. 4 Despite being in high numbers in medical colleges, only a small proportion of these women join the workforce, particularly in South Asian countries. 5 Several studies have been conducted to determine the reasons behind this fallout. 4,6,7 One of the major causes of this fallout is the fixed gender roles in the society which expects the women to take care of the household while the men are expected to be the breadwinner for the family. 4 This disparity in gender representation has been observed in several instances in the West, especially in leadership positions in medicine. In the US, it has been reported that women in high-level leadership positions (Medical school dean, department chair) remain scarce. 8 In Pakistan, according to the list of private medical colleges issued by PMC (Pakistan Medical Commission), out of the 97 medical colleges, only 10 medical and dental colleges had a female deans/principal which makes only 10% of all colleges. Similarly, 22 (refer Figure 1) medical and dental colleges that were surveyed at the beginning of this study showed a huge disparity in the ratio of males and females at leadership positions. Figure 1 Percentage of females and males at senior leadership posts in ( A ) MBBS and ( B ) BDS colleges in Pakistan (n = 22). A good leader in healthcare should be approachable by welcoming the team members to voice their opinions while at the same time he or she should be able to balance autonomy and accountability. All of this should be carried out by prioritizing patient care and safety. 9 Apart from identifying the qualities required to be an effective leader, the role of gender differences in leadership has also been debated for a long time. Research has shown that there are differences in the performance of men and women as leaders, especiall -Abstract Truncated-