Two-spin relaxation of P-dimers in Silicon

Massoud Borhani,Xuedong Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.82.241302
2010-10-08
Abstract:We study two-electron singlet-triplet relaxation of donor-bound electrons in Silicon. Hyperfine interaction of the electrons with the phosphorus (P) nuclei, in combination with the electron-phonon interaction, lead to relaxation of the triplet states. Within the Heitler-London and effective mass approximations, we calculate the triplet relaxation rates in the presence of an applied magnetic field. This relaxation mechanism affects the resonance peaks in current Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) experiments on P-dimers. Moreover, the estimated time scales for the spin decay put an upper bound on the gate pulses needed to perform fault-tolerant two-qubit operations in donor-spin-based quantum computers (QCs).
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the two - electron spin singlet - triplet relaxation mechanisms of phosphorus dimers (P - dimers) in silicon. Specifically, the author studied the triplet relaxation process of phosphorus - donor - bound electrons under the combined action of hyperfine interaction and electron - phonon interaction. These problems are crucial for understanding the coherence and reliability of two - qubit operations in quantum computing architectures based on phosphorus - donor spins, such as the Kane architecture. ### Research Background 1. **Spin Properties of Phosphorus Donors in Silicon**: - The electron and nuclear spins of a single phosphorus donor in silicon have an extremely long coherence time. - The study of phosphorus dimers (two adjacent phosphorus donors) is relatively scarce because it is experimentally difficult to precisely control their positions and couplings. 2. **Applications in Quantum Computing**: - Phosphorus - donor spins can be used as qubits for implementing quantum computing. - The exchange interaction between two donors can be used to implement two - qubit operations. ### Core Problems of the Paper The main objective of the paper is to study, through theoretical calculations, the relaxation rate of two electron spins from the triplet state to the singlet state in phosphorus dimers and analyze the impact of this relaxation mechanism on quantum information processing. Specifically: - **Relaxation Mechanism**: The author studied how hyperfine interaction and electron - phonon interaction lead to the relaxation of the electron spin triplet state in phosphorus dimers. - **Influencing Factors**: The relaxation rate depends on the exchange splitting \(4J\), the dimer spacing \(d\), and their orientations along different symmetry axes of the crystal. - **Experimental Observation**: This relaxation mechanism will cause the broadening of peaks in electron spin resonance (ESR) experiments and can thus be experimentally observed. ### Main Results 1. **Calculation of Relaxation Rate**: - Using the Heitler - London approximation and the effective mass approximation, a formula for the relaxation rate from the triplet state to the singlet state was derived: \[ \Gamma_{T_0 \to S} \approx \alpha_1 (\Xi_d+\frac{1}{3}\Xi_u)^2 A^2 J (n_{q_0}+1) |I|^4 \] where \(\alpha_1\) is a constant, \(\Xi_d\) and \(\Xi_u\) are the volume - change potential and the shear - change potential respectively, \(A\) is the hyperfine coupling constant, \(J\) is the exchange energy, \(n_{q_0}\) is the Bose - Einstein distribution of phonons, and \(I\) is the overlap integral of the left - and right - donor wave functions. 2. **Dependence of Relaxation Time**: - The relaxation time \(T_1\) decreases as the exchange splitting \(4J\) increases, showing an almost cubic dependence. - For dimers in different directions (such as [001], [011], and [111] directions), the relaxation time can vary from a few microseconds to several hundred milliseconds. 3. **Experimental Significance**: - This relaxation mechanism will affect the upper time limit of two - qubit gate operations in current quantum computing architectures based on phosphorus - donor spins. - Experimentally, this relaxation mechanism can be verified by measuring the line width of the ESR peak. ### Conclusion The paper reveals, through theoretical calculations, the mechanism of electron spin triplet relaxation in phosphorus dimers and points out that this mechanism has an important impact on quantum computing based on phosphorus - donor spins. In particular, the relaxation time strongly depends on the spacing and orientation of the dimers, which poses strict requirements for the practical implementation of quantum computing architectures.