High Voltage Vacuum Interrupters; Technical and Physical Feasibility versus Economical Efficiency

R. Renz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/deiv.2006.357281

2006-01-01

Abstract:Tn the medium voltage range the vacuum switching principle is well established (Fink and Renz, 2002). Today vacuum circuit breakers are available up to 52 kV rated voltage and 80 kA short-circuit current. By using a series arrangement of two or more vacuum interrupters it is basically possible to double or multiply the dielectric strength without increasing the operating energy substantially. Applications with two 24 kV or 36 kV standard vacuum interrupters in series for rated voltages of 52kV or 72kV are well known. In principle there is no restriction on the medium voltage range for single vacuum interrupters. Tubes for 72kV and even 145kV applications are described by several manufacturers. However due to a nearly square-root dependence between the dielectric strength and the contact stroke it is not trivial to find acceptable solutions. Concerning environmentally aspects also the external insulation of the interrupter causes problems. SF6 is well established in compact gas-insulated switchgears (GTS). Of course designs for air-insulated switchgears (AIS) are possible. But adequate solutions have to be found. Another issue to be considered is the interrupting capability. The dependence on contact stroke for conventional contact systems may limit short circuit current interrupting capability. The higher the stroke the lower the maximum current, which can be proper, interrupted. Increasing of the contact diameter ad infinitum is useless. Switching capacitors is the next technical challenge. On one side a dielectric sufficient stroke is necessary, on the other side increasing contact gap reduces the interrupting capability. Overvoltages produced by switching inductances also deserve closer attentions. Common contact materials for medium voltage vacuum interrupters are maybe not suited for low surge behaviour in high voltage devices. Together with the electrical items the mechanical stability of the interrupter has not to be sneezed at. The endurance of the bellows and housing as well as the bending and upsetting of the conduction bolts demand high sophisticated engineering. In spite of all the technical problems proper solutions up to 72kV were developed in the past and 145kV-bottles with a single interrupter gap are possible. The main handicap against the introduction of vacuum technology into the high voltage domain is obviously the economical efficiency. Well established technologies and production facilities enable cost-effective products today. A decision pro vacuum is possible for high voltage applications as recently as technical and commercial solutions are available