Abstract:In the histories formulation of quantum theory, sets of coarse-grained histories, that are called consistent, obey classical probability rules. It has been argued that these sets can describe the semi-classical behaviour of closed quantum systems. Most physical scenarios admit multiple different consistent sets and one can view each consistent set as a separate context. Using propositions from different consistent sets to make inferences leads to paradoxes such as the contrary inferences first noted by Kent [Physical Review Letters, 78(15):2874, 1997]. Proponents of the consistent histories formulation argue that one should not mix propositions coming from different consistent sets in making logical arguments, and that paradoxes such as the aforementioned contrary inferences are nothing else than the usual microscopic paradoxes of quantum contextuality as first demonstrated by Kochen and Specker theorem. In this contribution we use the consistent histories to describe a macroscopic (semi-classical) system to show that paradoxes involving contextuality (mixing different consistent sets) persist even in the semi-classical limit. This is distinctively different from the contextuality of standard quantum theory, where the contextuality paradoxes do not persist in the semi-classical limit. Specifically, we consider different consistent sets for the arrival time of a semi-classical wave packet in an infinite square well. Surprisingly, we get consistent sets that disagree on whether the motion of the semi-classical system, that started within a subregion, ever left that subregion or not. Our results point to the need for constraints, additional to the consistency condition, to recover the correct semi-classical limit in this formalism and lead to the motto `all consistent sets are equal', but `some consistent sets are more equal than others'.

Critique of weakly decohering and linearly positive histories

Partial Decoherence of Histories and the Diosi Test

Anomalies of weakened decoherence criteria for quantum histories

Linearly Positive Histories: Probabilities for a Robust Family of Sequences of Quantum Events

Strong Decoherence

The Geometry of Consistency: Decohering Histories in Generalized Quantum Theory

Decoherent Histories and Realism

Homogeneous decoherence functionals in standard and history quantum mechanics

Symmetries of Decoherence Functionals

Sea quark and gluon polarization in the nucleon at NLO accuracy

A First Principles Numerical Demonstration of Emergent Decoherent Histories

Bohmian histories and decoherent histories

Decoherent Histories Quantum Mechanics with One 'Real' Fine-Grained History

Decoherent Histories Quantum Mechanics Starting with Records of What Happens

On the Consistent Effect Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Alternative Decohering Histories in Quantum Mechanics

Quantum temporal logic and decoherence functionals in the histories approach to generalised quantum theory

Remarks on Consistent Histories and Bohmian Mechanics

Decoherence of Histories: Chaotic Versus Integrable Systems

Comment on ``Consistent Sets Yield Contrary Inferences in Quantum Theory''

Contrary Inferences for Classical Histories within the Consistent Histories Formulation of Quantum Theory