Do Quantum Systems Break The Equivalence Principle?

Timir Datta,Ming Yin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0908.3885
2009-08-27
Abstract:Gravitational response of real objects is a fascinating topic. Einstein formalized the Galileo-Newton ideas of equality of free falls into complete physical equivalence or the Principle of Equivalence [Albert Einstein, The meaning of Relativity, 5 ed. Princeton, (1921)]. However, in this article we point out that in a gravitational field, g, the bulk response of an electrically neutral but atomistic test mass is model dependant. Depending on the particular quantum approximation scheme, opposing results for the gravity induced (electric) polarization P have been reported. For instance, P is small and oriented anti-parallel to g, if the deformations of the positive background lattice is neglected But, it is about ~ 100,1000 times larger and opposite in direction in the elastic lattice approximation. Hence, the elastic model contradicts reports of polarization in accelerated metals [Richard C. Tolman & <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://T.Dale" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> Stewart, Phys Rev 28, 794 (1926); G. F. Moorhead & G. I. Opat, Class. Quant. Grav, 13, 3129 (1996)]. Surprisingly, the rigid system is consistent with EP but the elastic system breaks EP. Here the historical literature is surveyed and some implications are outlined.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore whether quantum systems violate the Equivalence Principle (EP). Specifically, the paper focuses on whether the bulk response of electrically neutral atomic - structure test masses in a gravitational field will produce different results due to different quantum approximation schemes. For example, if the deformation of the positive background lattice is ignored, the gravitational - induced (electric) polarization \(P_g\) is small and its direction is opposite to that of the gravitational force \(g\); while under the elastic lattice approximation, \(P_g\) is five orders of magnitude larger and has the opposite direction. Therefore, the paper points out that the rigid system is consistent with the Equivalence Principle, while the elastic system may violate it. By reviewing historical literature and proposing direct experiments, the author aims to clarify these issues regarding the gravitational response of quantum systems.