Abstract:After providing an extensive overview of the conceptual elements -- such as Einstein's `hole argument' -- that underpin Penrose's proposal for gravitationally induced quantum state reduction, the proposal is constructively criticised. Penrose has suggested a mechanism for objective reduction of quantum states with postulated collapse time T = h/E, where E is an ill-definedness in the gravitational self-energy stemming from the profound conflict between the principles of superposition and general covariance. Here it is argued that, even if Penrose's overall conceptual scheme for the breakdown of quantum mechanics is unreservedly accepted, his formula for the collapse time of superpositions reduces to T --> oo (E --> 0) in the strictly Newtonian regime, which is the domain of his proposed experiment to corroborate the effect. A suggestion is made to rectify this situation. In particular, recognising the cogency of Penrose's reasoning in the domain of full `quantum gravity', it is demonstrated that an appropriate experiment which could in principle corroborate his argued `macroscopic' breakdown of superpositions is not the one involving non-rotating mass distributions as he has suggested, but a Leggett-type SQUID or BEC experiment involving superposed mass distributions in relative rotation. The demonstration thereby brings out one of the distinctive characteristics of Penrose's scheme, rendering it empirically distinguishable from other state reduction theories involving gravity. As an aside, a new geometrical measure of gravity-induced deviation from quantum mechanics in the manner of Penrose is proposed, but now for the canonical commutation relations [Q, P] = ih.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the profound conflict between quantum mechanics and gravity, specifically the problem of the collapse of quantum superposition states on the macroscopic scale. The author explores this problem by criticizing and analyzing Penrose's theory of objective reduction (OR) of the quantum state induced by gravity. ### Problem Background 1. **Measurement Problem**: - Quantum mechanics allows physical objects to have potential, undetermined properties (potentialities), while objects in our everyday world exhibit definite actual properties (actualities). How to transition from potentiality to actuality is an unresolved problem. - The lack of this transition mechanism has led to the so - called "measurement problem". 2. **Penrose's Theory of Gravity - Induced Quantum State Reduction**: - Penrose proposed a mechanism, believing that gravity can induce the objective reduction of the quantum state. He assumed a formula to describe the time scale of this reduction: \[ \tau=\frac{\hbar}{\Delta E} \] where \(\Delta E\) is the uncertainty of the gravitational self - energy resulting from the conflict between the superposition principle of quantum mechanics and the covariance principle of general relativity. ### Main Contributions of the Paper 1. **Criticizing Penrose's Formula**: - The author points out that in the limit of strict Newtonian gravity (i.e., the non - relativistic regime), Penrose's formula will lead to the collapse time \(\tau\rightarrow\infty\) (because \(\Delta E\rightarrow0\)), which means that the standard quantum coherence will remain unchanged, and this is clearly not as expected. 2. **Suggesting an Improved Experimental Design**: - The author believes that the appropriate experiment capable of verifying Penrose's predicted effect is not the experiment he proposed involving non - rotating mass distributions, but should be Leggett - type SQUID (superconducting quantum interference device) or BEC (Bose - Einstein condensate) experiments, which involve relatively rotating mass distributions. - This experimental design can better reveal the unique features of Penrose's scheme, distinguishing it from other quantum state reduction theories involving gravity. 3. **Proposing a New Geometric Measure**: - The author also proposes a new geometric measure to quantify the degree of deviation from quantum mechanics caused by gravity, especially for the canonical commutation relation \([Q, P]=i\hbar\). ### Summary This paper, through a critical analysis of Penrose's theory of gravity - induced quantum state reduction, points out its limitations in the non - relativistic regime and makes improvement suggestions. The author emphasizes that an appropriate experimental design is crucial for verifying this theory and proposes a new geometric measure method to quantify the influence of gravity on quantum mechanics. These works contribute to a further understanding of the relationship between quantum mechanics and gravity and provide directions for future research.

Why the Quantum Must Yield to Gravity

Does gravity induce wavefunction collapse? An examination of Penrose's conjecture

Quantum Theory Needs (And Probably Has) Real Reduction

Gravitational quantum collapse in dilute systems

Is it time to rethink quantum gravity?

A Gravitational Theory of the Quantum

Testing Models of 'Gravity' Using a Quantum Computer

Quantum Gravity - Testing Time for Theories

The Necessity of Quantizing Gravity

A postquantum theory of classical gravity?

Exploring the unification of quantum theory and general relativity with a Bose-Einstein condensate

On Gravity Implication in the Wavefunction Collapse

Implementation of the Quantum Equivalence Principle

Gravity in quantum spacetime

Inequivalence between gravitational mass and energy due to quantum effects at microscopic and macroscopic levels

How to quantize gravity and how not to quantize gravity

When Cavendish meets Feynman: A quantum torsion balance for testing the quantumness of gravity

Gravitation, and quantum theory, as emergent phenomena

Testing Whether Gravity Acts as a Quantum Entity When Measured

Quantum Gravity: Has Spacetime Quantum Properties?

Underground test of gravity-related wave function collapse