Abstract:In Fortsch. Phys. $\textbf{64}$, 176 (2016), Alvarez-Gaume et al established that pure $R^2$ theory propagates $\textit{massless}$ spin-2 graviton on a de Sitter (dS) background but $\textit{not}$ on a locally flat background. We build on this insight to derive a Newtonian limit for the theory. Unlike most previous works that linearized the metric around a locally flat background, we explicitly employ the dS background to start with. We directly solve the field equation of the action $(2\kappa)^{-1}\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\,R^2$ coupled with the stress-energy tensor of normal matter in the form $T_{\mu\nu}=Mc^2\,\delta(\vec{r})\,\delta_\mu^0\,\delta_\nu^0$. We obtain the following Schwarzschild-de Sitter metric $ds^{2}=-\Bigl(1-\frac{\Lambda}{3}r^{2}-\frac{\kappa c^{2}}{48\pi\Lambda}\frac{M}{r}\Bigr)c^2dt^2+\Bigl(1-\frac{\Lambda}{3}r^2-\frac{\kappa c^2}{48\pi\Lambda}\frac{M}{r}\Bigr)^{-1}dr^2+r^2d\Omega^2$ which features a potential $V(r)=-\frac{\kappa c^4}{96\pi\Lambda}\frac{M}{r}$ with the correct Newtonian tail. The parameter $\Lambda$ plays a dual role: (i) it sets the scalar curvature for the background dS metric, and (ii) it partakes in the Newtonian potential $V(r)$. We reach two key findings. Firstly, the Newtonian limit only emerges owing to the de Sitter background. Most existing studies of the Newtonian limit in modified gravity chose to linearize the metric around a locally flat background. However, this is a $\textit{false}$ vacuum to start with for pure $R^2$ gravity. These studies unknowingly omitted the information about $\Lambda$ of the de Sitter background, hence incapable of attaining a Newtonian behavior in pure $R^2$ gravity. Secondly, as $\Lambda$ appears in $V(r)$ in a $\textit{singular}$ manner, viz. $V(r)\propto\Lambda^{-1}$, the Newtonian limit for pure $R^2$ gravity cannot be obtained by any perturbative approach treating $\Lambda$ as a small parameter.

Stability of a metric f(R) gravity theory implies the Newtonian limit

Metric gravity theories and cosmology:II. Stability of a ground state in f(R) theories

Metric gravity theories and cosmology. I. Physical interpretation and viability

Test-field limit of metric nonlinear gravity theories

Incompatibility of gravity theories with auxiliary fields with the standard model

Stability analysis for a cosmologically viable model of $f(R)$ gravity

On Shear-free perturbations of f(R) gravity

Emerging Newtonian potential in pure $R^2$ gravity on a de Sitter background

The Newtonian limit of orthonormal frames in metric theories of gravity

Particles and their fluids in nontrivial matter extensions to general relativity

Physical non-viability of a wide class of $f(R)$ models and their constant-curvature solutions

Thermodynamics of $f(R)$ Gravity: The Double Well Potential Case

Asymptotically Safe Gravity As a Scalar-Tensor Theory and Its Cosmological Implications

Stability of the de-Sitter universe: One-loop nonlocal $f(R)$ gravity

Does the stability of f(R) theories imply the stability of the dual scalar-tensor theory ?

Compact stars in scalar-tensor theories with a single-well potential and the corresponding $f(R)$ theory

Constant curvature f(R) gravity minimally coupled with Yang-Mills field

The Euclidean-hyperboloidal foliation method: application to f(R) modified gravity

Hydrostatic equilibrium configurations of neutron stars in the $f(R,\mathcal{L},T)$ gravity theory

Dynamical stability of Minkowski space in higher order gravity