First-principles investigation of Ag-Cu alloy surfaces in an oxidizing environment

Simone Piccinin,Catherine Stampfl,Matthias Scheffler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.77.075426
2007-12-21
Abstract:In this paper we investigate by means of first-principles density functional theory calculations the (111) surface of the Ag-Cu alloy under varying conditions of pressure of the surrounding oxygen atmosphere and temperature. This alloy has been recently proposed as a catalyst with improved selectivity for ethylene epoxidation with respect to pure silver, the catalyst commonly used in industrial applications. Here we show that the presence of oxygen leads to copper segregation to the surface. Considering the surface free energy as a function of the surface composition, we construct the convex hull to investigate the stability of various surface structures. By including the dependence of the free surface energy on the oxygen chemical potential, we are able compute the phase diagram of the alloy as a function of temperature, pressure and surface composition. We find that, at temperature and pressure typically used in ethylene epoxidation, a number of structures can be present on the surface of the alloy, including clean Ag(111), thin layers of copper oxide and thick oxide-like structures. These results are consistent with, and help explain, recent experimental results.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the surface structure and its stability of Ag - Cu alloys in an oxidizing environment, especially under different oxygen pressure and temperature conditions. Specifically, the research aims to understand the influence of oxygen on the segregation of copper on the Ag(111) surface and determine the stability of different surface structures through first - principles calculations. This helps to explain and predict the performance of Ag - Cu alloys as catalysts in industrial applications (such as the ethylene epoxidation reaction). ### Main Problem Analysis 1. **Segregation of Copper on the Ag(111) Surface**: - Research shows that in an oxidizing environment, copper will segregate from the bulk phase to the Ag(111) surface. This phenomenon is crucial for understanding the catalytic performance of Ag - Cu alloys. 2. **Stability of Surface Structures**: - By considering the surface free energy, constructing a convex hull is used to evaluate the stability of different surface structures. These structures include pure Ag(111), thin - layer CuO, thick oxide structures, etc. 3. **Construction of Phase Diagrams**: - By introducing the chemical potential of oxygen, the phase diagrams under different temperatures, pressures, and surface compositions are calculated. This helps to understand the surface structures that may occur under actual catalytic conditions. 4. **Consistency of Experimental Results**: - The research results are consistent with recent experimental results and help to explain the experimentally observed phenomena, such as the segregation of copper on the surface and the existence of different oxide structures. ### Formula Summary - **Average Binding Energy of Oxygen Atoms**: \[ E_b^{\text{O/Ag}} = -\frac{1}{N_O} \left[ E_{\text{O/Ag}} - (E_{\text{slab}} + N_O E_O) \right] \] where \( N_O \) is the number of oxygen atoms in the unit cell, \( E_{\text{O/Ag}} \) is the energy of the total system, \( E_{\text{slab}} \) is the energy of the silver substrate, and \( E_O \) is the energy of half an oxygen molecule. - **Change in Gibbs Free Energy**: \[ \Delta G(\mu_O) = \frac{1}{A} \left( G_{\text{O/Ag}} - G_{\text{slab}} - \Delta N_{\text{Ag}} \mu_{\text{Ag}} - N_O \mu_O \right) \] where \( G_{\text{O/Ag}} \) is the free energy of the adsorbed state/substrate structure, \( G_{\text{slab}} \) is the free energy of the clean silver substrate, \( \Delta N_{\text{Ag}} \) is the difference in the number of silver atoms between the adsorption system and the clean silver substrate, and \( \mu_{\text{Ag}} \) and \( \mu_O \) are the chemical potentials of silver and oxygen, respectively. - **Oxygen Chemical Potential**: \[ \mu_O(T, p) = \frac{1}{2} \left[ E_{\text{total}}^{O_2}(T, p_0) + \tilde{\mu}_{O_2}(T, p_0) + k_B T \ln \left( \frac{p_{O_2}}{p_0} \right) \right] \] Through these studies, the authors hope to provide a theoretical basis for understanding and designing efficient Ag - Cu alloy catalysts, especially for their application in the ethylene epoxidation reaction.