Abstract:What do binary (or probabilistic) forecasting abilities have to do with overall performance? We map the difference between (univariate) binary predictions, bets and "beliefs" (expressed as a specific "event" will happen/will not happen) and real-world continuous payoffs (numerical benefits or harm from an event) and show the effect of their conflation and mischaracterization in the decision-science literature. We also examine the differences under thin and fat tails. The effects are: A- Spuriousness of many psychological results particularly those documenting that humans overestimate tail probabilities and rare events, or that they overreact to fears of market crashes, ecological calamities, etc. Many perceived "biases" are just mischaracterizations by psychologists. There is also a misuse of Hayekian arguments in promoting prediction markets. We quantify such conflations with a metric for "pseudo-overestimation". B- Being a "good forecaster" in binary space doesn't lead to having a good actual performance}, and vice versa, especially under nonlinearities. A binary forecasting record is likely to be a reverse indicator under some classes of distributions. Deeper uncertainty or more complicated and realistic probability distribution worsen the conflation . C- Machine Learning: Some nonlinear payoff functions, while not lending themselves to verbalistic expressions and "forecasts", are well captured by ML or expressed in option contracts. D- Fattailedness: The difference is exacerbated in the power law classes of probability distributions.

The relativistic velocity addition law optimizes a forecast gambler's profit

Probabilistic recalibration of forecasts

Non-probabilistic odds and forecasting with imperfect models

Optimizing Investment Strategies with Lazy Factor and Probability Weighting: A Price Portfolio Forecasting and Mean-Variance Model with Transaction Costs Approach

On the relation between forecast precision and trading profitability of financial analysts

Optimal probabilistic forecasts for risk management

Portfolio optimization beyond utility maximization: the case of driftless markets

Sequential optimizing strategy in multi-dimensional bounded forecasting games

Online Learning in Betting Markets: Profit versus Prediction

Calibrated Forecasting and Persuasion

On the optimal forecast with the fractional Brownian motion

On the Statistical Differences between Binary Forecasts and Real World Payoffs

Probabilistic forecast reconciliation under the Gaussian framework

A Spliced Gamma-Generalized Pareto Model for Short-Term Extreme Wind Speed Probabilistic Forecasting

A puzzle of roulette gambling

Enhancement of prediction algorithms by betting

The On-Line Rental Problem With Risk And Probabilistic Forecast

An adaptive volatility method for probabilistic forecasting and its application to the M6 financial forecasting competition

Relativistic velocity addition law derived from a machine gun analogy and time dilation only

Risk-Aware Objective-Based Forecasting in Inertia Management

A Probabilistic View on the Adapted Wasserstein Distance