Abstract:We reanalyze Oklo $^{149}$Sm data using realistic models of the natural nuclear reactors. Disagreements among recent Oklo determinations of the time evolution of $\alpha$, the electromagnetic fine structure constant, are shown to be due to different reactor models, which led to different neutron spectra used in the calculations. We use known Oklo reactor epithermal spectral indices as criteria for selecting realistic reactor models. Two Oklo reactors, RZ2 and RZ10, were modeled with MCNP. The resulting neutron spectra were used to calculate the change in the $^{149}$Sm effective neutron capture cross section as a function of a possible shift in the energy of the 97.3-meV resonance. We independently deduce ancient $^{149}$Sm effective cross sections, and use these values to set limits on the time-variation of $\alpha$. Our study resolves a contradictory situation with previous Oklo $\alpha$-results. Our suggested $2 \sigma$ bound on a possible time variation of $\alpha$ over two billion years is stringent: $ -0.24 \times 10^{-7} \le \frac{\Delta \alpha}{\alpha} \le 0.11 \times 10^{-7}$, but model dependent in that it assumes only $\alpha$ has varied over time.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the existing controversy regarding the time evolution of the electromagnetic fine - structure constant ($\alpha$) in the data of the Oklo natural nuclear reactor. Specifically, by re - analyzing the data of the Oklo reactor, especially by using a more realistic reactor model to calculate the neutron spectrum, researchers aim to explain the different results of the $\alpha$ change rate among different studies. #### Background and Problem Description 1. **Background**: - The Oklo natural nuclear reactor, located in Gabon, was a nuclear reactor in a uranium mine that formed naturally 2 billion years ago. - These reactors provide a unique opportunity to study the change of physical constants (such as $\alpha$) over time. 2. **Problem**: - Different studies have given inconsistent results regarding the change of $\alpha$ in the Oklo reactor. For example, some studies suggest that $\alpha$ may have increased, while others suggest that it has decreased or has not changed. - These differences are mainly due to the use of different reactor models, resulting in different neutron spectra for calculation. #### Research Objectives - **Solve the Controversy**: Re - analyze the data of the Oklo reactor by using a more realistic reactor model (such as MCNP simulation) to explain these inconsistent results. - **Set Limits**: Based on the new analysis results, set strict limits for the change of $\alpha$ within the past 2 billion years. - **Verify the Model**: Ensure the reliability of the results by selecting a model that conforms to the known neutron - spectrum characteristics of the Oklo reactor. #### Main Contributions - Proposed using the known Oklo reactor neutron - spectrum index as a criterion for selecting an appropriate reactor model. - Through MCNP simulation, established detailed models of two Oklo reactors, RZ2 and RZ10, and calculated their neutron spectra. - Calculated the change of the effective neutron - capture cross - section of samarium - 149 (${}^{149}\text{Sm}$) with the resonance - energy shift. - Independently derived the effective cross - section of ancient ${}^{149}\text{Sm}$ and used these values to set the time - change limits of $\alpha$. #### Conclusion Through these methods, the researchers resolved the previous contradictory results regarding the change of $\alpha$ in the Oklo reactor and obtained a strict 2$\sigma$ limit: \[ - 0.24\times10^{-7}\leq\frac{\Delta\alpha}{\alpha}\leq0.11\times10^{-7} \] This result assumes that only $\alpha$ has changed in the past.

Time-variability of alpha from realistic models of Oklo reactors

The Oklo bound on the time variation of the fine-structure constant revisited

Oklo Constraint on the Time-Variability of the Fine-Structure Constant

Bound on the variation in the fine structure constant implied by Oklo data

Nuclear Data in Oklo and Time-Variability of Fundamental Coupling Constants

The Oklo Constraints on Alpha-Decay Half-Lives

Gamma-ray fluxes in Oklo natural reactors

Investigation of the fundamental constants stability based on the reactor Oklo burn-up analysis

The nuclear interaction at Oklo 2 billion years ago

Natural Nuclear Reactor Oklo and Variation of Fundamental Constants Part 1: Computation of Neutronics of Fresh Core

Oklo reactors and implications for nuclear science

Limits on the variability of coupling constants from the Oklo natural reactor

Direct Test of the Time-Independence of Fundamental Nuclear Constants Using the Oklo Natural Reactor

The Mystery of Alpha and the Isotopes

Lutetium thermometry for Oklo natural reactors: a new look at old data

Variation of fundamental constants: theory and observations

La138/139 Isotopic Data and Neutron Fluences for Oklo RZ10 Reactor

A five dimensional model of varying effective gravitational and fine structure constants

Optimization of the Coupling of High-Frequency Horn Antenna Array to the ESA PLANCK Submillimeter-Wave Telescope

Measuring the Time Variation of the Fine-structure Constant with Quasars Detected by LAMOST

Sensitivity of $^{229}$Th nuclear clock transition to variation of the fine-structure constant