Oklo Constraint on the Time-Variability of the Fine-Structure Constant

Yasunori Fujii

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/b13178

2003-11-17

Abstract:The Oklo phenomenon, natural fission reactors which had taken place in Gabon about 2 billion years ago, provides one of the most stringent constraints on the possible time-variability of the fine-structure constant $\alpha$. We first review briefly what it is and how reliable it is in constraining $\alpha$. We then compare the result with a more recent result on the nonzero change of $\alpha$ obtained from the observation of the QSO absorption lines. We suggest a possible way to make these results consistent with each other in terms of the behavior of a scalar field which is expected to be responsible for the acceleration of the universe.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the possibility and degree of the fine - structure constant (\(\alpha\)) changing over time. Specifically, by analyzing the data of Oklo natural reactors, the paper explores whether the fine - structure constant was different from what it is today 2 billion years ago. The Oklo phenomenon provides a strict limit on the time - variability of the fine - structure constant.

### Background of the paper
- **Oklo phenomenon**: Oklo, located in Gabon, Africa, is a natural uranium mine where natural nuclear fission reactions occurred approximately 2 billion years ago. The existence of these natural reactors provides a unique window for studying nuclear processes in the early Earth environment.
- **Fine - structure constant**: \(\alpha\) is a fundamental physical constant that describes the strength of electromagnetic interactions and has a value of approximately \(1/137\). In recent years, some observational results suggest that \(\alpha\) may change over time, especially in the early universe.

### Research methods
- **Shlyakhter's detection method**: Alex Shlyakhter proposed to estimate the change in \(\alpha\) by measuring the abundance of samarium - 149 (\(^{149}\text{Sm}\)) in the Oklo reactors. Samarium - 149 will absorb neutrons in the reactor to generate samarium - 150 (\(^{150}\text{Sm}\)), and the resonance energy of this process is very low and is very sensitive to the change in \(\alpha\).
- **Data analysis**: By measuring the isotope abundances in different samples and combining with theoretical models, the researchers calculated the cross - section \(\hat{\sigma}_{149}\) of samarium - 149 and further deduced the change range of the fine - structure constant.

### Main results
- **Shlyakhter's results**: Shlyakhter gave an upper limit of \(\Delta E_r\) as 50 meV, and thus deduced an upper limit of the change in \(\alpha\) as \(|\Delta \alpha / \alpha| < 2\times 10^{-8}\).
- **Re - analysis**: The author team re - analyzed the data, taking into account factors such as sample contamination, and obtained more accurate results. They found that \(\Delta E_r\) has two possible ranges: one close to zero (null), and the other significantly non - zero (non - null).
- **Comparison with QSO results**: The paper also discussed the consistency between the Oklo results and the quasar (QSO) absorption line observation results. The QSO observation results show that \(\Delta \alpha / \alpha=(- 0.54\pm0.12)\times 10^{-5}\), which is different from the Oklo results. The author proposed a possible explanation, that is, this difference can be explained by introducing a scalar field, which is responsible for the accelerated expansion of the universe.

### Conclusion
The paper strictly limits the time - variability of the fine - structure constant \(\alpha\) by detailed analysis of the data of Oklo natural nuclear reactors. Although there is some uncertainty, the research results provide an important reference for understanding the stability of fundamental physical constants. In addition, the author proposed a theoretical framework, attempting to unify the Oklo results and QSO observation results, which provides a new direction for further research.