Enhancing Biomass-to-Liquid conversion through synergistic integration of natural gas pyrolysis: process options and environmental implications
Mohammad Ostadi,Guiyan Zang,Leslie Bromberg,Daniel R. Cohn,Emre Gençer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2024.118142
IF: 10.4
2024-02-03
Energy Conversion and Management
Abstract:Low-carbon liquid fuels are needed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in sectors reliant on liquid fuels/chemicals, such as transportation as well as other difficult to electrify sectors. A range of biomass feedstocks is a renewable carbon source which holds substantial promise for generating low-carbon liquid fuel through, for example, the Biomass-to-Liquid (BTL) gasification process. However, biomass availability is limited, and it is hydrogen-lean; consequently, syngas generated from biomass through gasification is hydrogen deficient for converting all of the biomass carbon to methanol. By supplementing external low-carbon hydrogen, in other words "hydrogen-enhancement", the biomass carbon conversion efficiency of the process can be increased by around a factor of two for methanol. Production of low-carbon hydrogen from natural gas pyrolysis is showing promise as a substantially lower cost alternative to widely known water electrolysis. Because of the endothermic nature of natural gas pyrolysis reaction, providing the heat required by the process impacts the carbon and thermal efficiencies of the overall biomass to liquid fuel process. We have developed a framework in which five different integration options of natural gas pyrolysis within a thermochemical biomass to fuel process are analyzed. As an illustrative case for the developed framework, methanol production from an illustrative biomass feedstock (woody biomass) is considered. The five integration options considered include natural gas combustion, syngas combustion, hydrogen combustion, heat integration within the process (no external heating), as well as electrical heating to provide heat for the pyrolyzer. Technoeconomic and net greenhouse gas (GHG) analyses of each of these options on the methanol production are performed. The technoeconomic analysis indicates that for an illustrative pyrolysis process using molten material, the costs of methanol that is produced is in the range of ∼ 470/tonne (assuming sale of the byproduct carbon at a price of 475 to $ 500/tonne). Life cycle analysis (LCA) is used to assess net greenhouse gas emissions. The analysis indicates that fugitive methane emissions of natural gas are the major greenhouse contributor to net greenhouse gas, for a fugitive emissions percentage of 1 %, and that illustrative greenhouse gas emission reductions for hydrogen-enhanced biomass to methanol relative to natural-gas-based methanol are 80 % for the 100-year GWP (global warming potential) and 70 % for the 20-year GWP.
energy & fuels,thermodynamics,mechanics