Playing with the critical point. An experiment with the Mandelbrot set connectivity

Alessandro Rosa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.math/0608392
2006-08-15
Abstract:By means of a graphical journey across the Mandelbrot set for the classic quadratic iterator $f(z):z^2+q$, we illustrate how connectivity breaks as the seed $z_0$ is no longer at the critical point of $f(z)$. Finally we suggest an attack to the MLC conjecture.
History and Overview,Dynamical Systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore what changes will occur in the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set when the initial point \(z_0\) is no longer at the critical point. Specifically, the author experimentally studied how the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set of the classical quadratic iterative function \(f(z) = z^2+q\) is disrupted when the initial point deviates from the critical point. ### Problem Background The Mandelbrot set \(M\) is generated by the following nonlinear mapping: \[f(z, q)=z^2 + q\] where both \(z\) and \(q\) are complex numbers, and \(q\) is a parameter. The key concepts originate from the earlier work of Fatou and Julia. They studied the changes in the connectivity of the Julia set under the perturbation of the parameter \(q\) and proposed the famous theorem: there exists a critical point \(c\) in any attracting basin, and its forward orbit can reveal the dynamic properties of the complex mapping. ### Research Questions The paper mainly explores the following two questions: 1. **What changes will occur in the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set \(M\) when the initial point \(z_0\) is perturbed and no longer at the critical point?** Through graphical presentation and experiments, the author found that as the initial point moves away from the critical point, the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set is gradually lost, especially in the peripheral area. The central cardioid region will also be deformed and gradually shrink. 2. **Does the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set depend on whether the initial point \(z_0\) is at the critical point?** If so, then one can try to solve the MLC conjecture (Mandelbrot local connectivity conjecture) by proving that the Mandelbrot set is always disconnected when the initial point is not at the critical point. The MLC conjecture states that the Mandelbrot set is locally connected, that is, it does not contain one - dimensional filaments. ### Experimental Methods The author conducted experiments along the real and imaginary axes by changing the real and imaginary parts of the parameter \(q\) respectively to observe the changes in the Mandelbrot set. The results show that as the initial point moves away from the critical point, the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set is gradually lost, and in particular, obvious disconnections occur in the peripheral area. The central cardioid region also undergoes significant deformation. ### Conclusions and Prospects The author proposed a reverse - thinking approach to attack the MLC conjecture: by proving that the Mandelbrot set is always disconnected when the initial point is not at the critical point, thus indirectly supporting the MLC conjecture. Although this idea may be naive, the author hopes that this reverse thinking can provide a new perspective for solving the MLC conjecture. ### Graphical Presentation The paper is accompanied by a series of graphs showing the changes in the Mandelbrot set under different initial point positions, intuitively presenting the process of connectivity changes. For example: - When \(R = 0.0, I=- 0.1\), a slight disconnection occurs in the peripheral area. - When \(R = 0.0, I = - 0.9\), the cardioid region almost disappears. - When \(R = 1.6, I = 0.0\), the Mandelbrot set finally becomes a line. These graphs provide important visual evidence for understanding the connectivity of the Mandelbrot set.