Abstract:We derive from Einstein equation an evolution law for the area of a trapping or dynamical horizon. The solutions to this differential equation show a causal behavior. Moreover, in a viscous fluid analogy, the equation can be interpreted as an energy balance law, yielding to a positive bulk viscosity. These two features contrast with the event horizon case, where the non-causal evolution of the area and the negative bulk viscosity require teleological boundary conditions. This reflects the local character of trapping horizons as opposed to event horizons. Interpreting the area as the entropy, we propose to use an area/entropy evolution principle to select a unique dynamical horizon and time slicing in the Cauchy evolution of an initial marginally trapped surface.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the evolution law of the black hole event - horizon area and its relationship with the entropy principle. Specifically, the author focuses on the area evolution of the future - outer - trapping horizon (FOTH) and the dynamical horizon (DH), and compares them with the event horizon (EH). The main problems include:
1. **Derive the area evolution law of the trapping horizon or the dynamical horizon**:
- Starting from the Einstein equation, derive the differential equation that describes the area evolution of the trapping horizon or the dynamical horizon.
- These solutions exhibit causal behavior, while the area evolution of the event horizon is non - causal.
2. **Interpret the area evolution equation as an energy balance equation**:
- In the viscous fluid analogy, the area evolution equation can be interpreted as an internal energy balance equation, thus obtaining a positive volume viscosity.
- This is in contrast to the negative volume viscosity of the event horizon, which requires far - future boundary conditions to be stabilized.
3. **Interpret the area as entropy and propose an entropy evolution principle**:
- Interpret the area as entropy, and propose a principle based on area/entropy evolution to select the unique dynamical horizon and time slice.
- Discuss the maximum entropy production rate and the time convexity requirement (which can be interpreted as the Clausius - Duhem inequality) to select the appropriate dynamical horizon.
### Formula summary
- **Area evolution equation**:
\[
\frac{d^{2}A}{dt^{2}}+\bar{\kappa}'\frac{dA}{dt}=\int_{S_{t}}\left[8\pi T(m, h)+\sigma(h):\sigma(m)+\frac{(\theta(h))^{2}}{2}+(\bar{\kappa}'-\kappa')\theta(h)\right]\epsilon_{S}
\]
where \(A(t)=\int_{S_{t}}\epsilon_{S}\), \(\epsilon_{S}\) is the area element of the two - dimensional surface \(S_{t}\), \(\theta(h)\) is the expansion rate in the \(h\) direction, \(\sigma(h)\) is the shear tensor, \(T(m, h)\) is the energy - momentum tensor component of the matter, and \(\bar{\kappa}'\) is the average value.
- **Energy dissipation and volume viscosity**:
\[
L_{h}\varepsilon+\theta(h)\varepsilon = -\frac{\kappa}{8\pi}\theta(h)+\frac{1}{8\pi}\sigma(h):\sigma(m)+\frac{(\theta(h))^{2}}{16\pi}-D\cdot Q+T(m, h)-\frac{\theta(k)}{8\pi}L_{h}C
\]
where \(\varepsilon=\frac{\theta(h)}{8\pi}\), \(Q = \frac{1}{4\pi}[C\vec{\Omega}(\ell)-\frac{1}{2}\vec{D}C]\), \(\vec{\Omega}(\ell)\) is the non - holonomy 1 - form of the surface \(S_{t}\).
- **Entropy evolution and dynamical horizon selection**:
\[
\ddot{a}=F[\text{sources}]+\alpha\frac{\theta(h)}{C}L_{h}C+\beta\frac{\theta(h)}{C}L_{h}L_{h}C
\]
where \(\ddot{a}=L_{h}\theta(h)+(\theta(h))^{2}\), \(F[\text{sources}]\) is the source term, and \(\alpha\) and \(\beta\) are undetermined parameters.
Through these formulas, the author hopes to reveal the role of the dynamical horizon in the black hole evolution.