Abstract:In black hole thermodynamics, defining coarse-grained entropy for dynamical black holes has long been a challenge, and various proposals, such as generalized entropy, have been explored. Guided by the AdS/CFT, we introduce a new definition of coarse-grained entropy for a dynamical black hole in Lorentzian Einstein gravity. On each time slice, this entropy is defined as the horizon area of an auxiliary Euclidean black hole that shares the same mass, (angular) momenta, and asymptotic normalizable matter modes with the original Lorentzian solution. The entropy is shown to satisfy a generalized first law and, through holography, the second law as well. Furthermore, by applying this thermodynamics to several Vaidya models in AdS and flat spacetime, we discover a connection between the second law and the null energy condition.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to define the coarse - grained entropy of black holes in non - equilibrium states and explore their thermodynamic laws. Specifically, by introducing a new definition of coarse - grained entropy, the paper aims to overcome the challenges encountered by existing methods in dealing with dynamic black holes, such as the inapplicability of the generalized entropy definition in some cases. Using the AdS/CFT correspondence principle, the paper proposes a new method for defining coarse - grained entropy, which is applicable to dynamic black holes in Lorentz - Einstein gravity. The coarse - grained entropy defined in the paper is related to the horizon area of an auxiliary Euclidean black hole, which has the same mass, angular momentum, and asymptotically normalized matter modes as the original Lorentzian solution. Through this method, the paper shows that the defined entropy satisfies the generalized first law and, through the holographic principle, the second law. In addition, by applying this thermodynamic framework to several Vaidya models, the paper discovers the connection between the second law and the zero - energy condition.
### Main contributions
1. **New definition of coarse - grained entropy**: The paper proposes a new definition of coarse - grained entropy based on the horizon area of an auxiliary Euclidean black hole, which is applicable to dynamic black holes.
2. **Verification of thermodynamic laws**: It is proved that the newly defined entropy satisfies the generalized first law and the second law.
3. **Application examples**: By applying this thermodynamic framework in Vaidya models in AdS and flat spacetimes, the validity of the theory is further verified, and the connection between the second law and the zero - energy condition is discovered.
### Method overview
- **Boundary quantum field theory**: Starting from the perspective of boundary quantum field theory, the coarse - grained state and the second law are derived from the positivity of relative entropy.
- **Path integral representation**: The path integral representations of the coarse - grained state and the original state are formalized, providing a basis for the subsequent gravitational description.
- **Gravitational description**: Using the AdS/CFT correspondence principle, the results of the boundary quantum field theory are translated into the language of gravity, the coarse - grained entropy is defined, and the corresponding thermodynamic laws are derived.
### Results
- **Definition of coarse - grained entropy**: On each time slice, the coarse - grained entropy is defined as the horizon area of an auxiliary Euclidean black hole that has the same mass, angular momentum, and asymptotically normalized matter modes as the original Lorentzian solution.
- **Thermodynamic laws**: It is proved that the newly defined entropy satisfies the generalized first law and the second law.
- **Application verification**: Through applications in several Vaidya models, the validity of the theory is verified, and the connection between the second law and the zero - energy condition is revealed.
### Formula examples
- **Relative entropy**:
\[
S(\rho_1 \| \rho_2) := \text{Tr}(\rho_1 \ln \rho_1 - \rho_1 \ln \rho_2)
\]
- **Coarse - grained entropy**:
\[
S_t := -\text{Tr}(\rho_{\text{ref}, t} \ln \rho_{\text{ref}, t})
\]
- **Horizon area of the auxiliary Euclidean solution**:
\[
S_t = \text{Area of the horizon of the auxiliary Euclidean black hole}
\]
Through these methods and results, the paper provides new perspectives and tools for understanding the thermodynamic properties of dynamic black holes.