Black hole entropy from non-Dirichlet sectors, and bounce solution

I. Y. Park

2023-08-01

Abstract:In a series of recent works the relevance of gravitational boundary degrees of freedom and their dynamics in gravity quantization and black hole information has been explored. In this work we further the progress by keenly focusing on the boundary degrees of freedom as the origin of black hole entropy. Wald's entropy formula is scrutinized, and the reason that the Wald's formula correctly captures the entropy of a black hole is examined. Afterwards, limitations of the Wald's method are discussed; a coherent view of entropy based on boundary dynamics is presented. The discrepancy observed in the literature between holographic and Wald's entropies is addressed. We generalize the entropy definition so as to handle a time-dependent black hole. Large gauge symmetry plays a pivotal role. Non-Dirichlet boundary conditions and gravitational analogues of Coleman-De Luccia bounce solutions are central in identifying the microstates and differentiating the origins of entropies associated with different classes of solutions. The result in the present work leads to a view that black hole entropy is entanglement entropy in a thermodynamic setup.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the nature of black - hole entropy and its relationship with boundary dynamics, especially how to identify the microscopic states of black holes through non - Dirichlet boundary conditions and gravitational Coleman - De Luccia - like tunneling solutions, and distinguish the entropy sources of different solution categories. Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Deepen the understanding of gravitational boundary degrees of freedom**: The author pays special attention to the genuine gravitational boundary degrees of freedom as the origin of black - hole entropy and explores how these degrees of freedom affect the black - hole information problem.

2. **Re - examine the Wald entropy formula**: The paper analyzes in detail why the Wald entropy formula can correctly capture black - hole entropy, discusses the limitations of the Wald method, and proposes a coherent view of entropy based on boundary dynamics.

3. **Resolve the differences in the literature**: The paper attempts to resolve the inconsistency between holographic entropy and Wald entropy in the literature by generalizing the entropy definition to deal with time - dependent black holes.

4. **Introduce large - gauge symmetry**: Large - gauge symmetry plays a crucial role in identifying the microscopic states of black holes and distinguishing the entropy sources of different solution categories. The paper emphasizes the importance of non - Dirichlet boundary conditions and gravitational Coleman - De Luccia - like tunneling solutions in this process.

5. **Propose a new perspective on black - hole entropy**: The paper finally concludes that black - hole entropy is entanglement entropy in a thermodynamic setting, and this view is supported by boundary dynamics.

### Specific technical goals

- **Generalize the Wald entropy formula**: The technical goal of the paper is to generalize the Wald entropy formula in order to systematically establish the general emergence of the Page curve from the first principles of pure gravitational physics.
- **In - depth study of the black - hole information paradox**: The paper explores various aspects of the black - hole information paradox, for example, regarding it as a special case of the "second law puzzle".
- **Use the Schrodinger framework**: The paper adopts the Schrodinger framework to study the black - hole information paradox in order to more widely handle various tasks, especially when identifying the initial (and final) vacuum states, which determine the dependence of the evaporation process on the initial collapse.

### Main contributions

- **Identify black - hole microscopic states**: By considering boundary degrees of freedom and large - gauge symmetry, the paper proposes a new method for identifying black - hole microscopic states.
- **Unify different methods**: The paper attempts to unify the Euclidean thermodynamic action method and the Noether method based on large - gauge symmetry, thereby better understanding black - hole entropy.
- **Resolve theoretical inconsistencies**: By introducing non - Dirichlet boundary conditions and gravitational Coleman - De Luccia - like tunneling solutions, the paper resolves the inconsistency between holographic entropy and Wald entropy.

In summary, through in - depth exploration of gravitational boundary degrees of freedom and large - gauge symmetry, this paper provides new perspectives and methods for understanding black - hole entropy and the black - hole information paradox.