Sergei L. Lukyanov,Philipp Werner
Abstract:We perform a numerical analysis of recently proposed scaling functions for the single electron box. Specifically, we study the ``magnetic'' susceptibility as a function of tunneling conductance and gate charge, and the effective charging energy at zero gate charge as a function of tunneling conductance in the strong tunneling limit. Our Monte Carlo results confirm the accuracy of the theoretical predictions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to solve some controversial issues of the single electron box in the strong tunneling limit. Specifically, the authors hope to verify the recently proposed universal scaling - behavior formula for the single electron box through numerical analysis. The main focuses are as follows:
1. **Magnetic Susceptibility**:
- Study the magnetic susceptibility as a function of tunneling conductance and gate charge.
- The formula is expressed as:
\[
\chi_m=\frac{2}{\beta^2}\int_0^\beta d\tau\int_0^\beta d\tau'\langle S_x(\tau)S_x(\tau')\rangle
\]
- Here \(S_x = \cos\phi\).
2. **Effective Charging Energy**:
- Study the effective charging energy at zero - gate charge as a function of tunneling conductance.
- The formula is expressed as:
\[
E_C^*=-\frac{1}{2\beta}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial n_G^2}\log(Z)
\]
In the past decade, there have been controversies regarding the analytical expressions of the single electron box in the large - tunneling - conductance limit. Previous numerical studies failed to clearly verify these predictions and even added confusion in some cases. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to conduct a comprehensive study of the recently obtained scaling formulas through state - of - the - art numerical techniques to resolve this unsatisfactory situation.
### Main Objectives
- **Verify theoretical predictions**: Verify the recently proposed scaling formulas, including the scaling behaviors of magnetic susceptibility and effective charging energy, through Monte Carlo simulations.
- **Resolve disputes**: In particular, resolve the disputes between different predictions regarding the pre - exponential factor \(f(\alpha)\) of the effective charging energy.
- **Provide accurate data**: Provide reliable numerical results for future theoretical and experimental studies, especially in the strong tunneling limit.
### Methods
The authors used the Ambegaokar - Eckern - Schön model and mapped the system onto a finite classical XY spin chain for numerical simulations. Through the Monte Carlo method, they studied the magnetic susceptibility and effective charging energy under different parameters and compared them with theoretical predictions.
### Results
- **Magnetic Susceptibility**: The Monte Carlo results are in very good agreement with the theoretical prediction in the scaling form, with an error between 0.5% and 2%.
- **Effective Charging Energy**: For the case of zero - gate charge, the Monte Carlo data are in very good agreement with the theoretical prediction, especially at lower temperatures.
- **Dispute Resolved**: Verified that the leading power of the pre - exponential factor \(f(\alpha)\) of the effective charging energy is \(\alpha^{3.6}\), thus resolving the dispute in the literature.
Overall, this paper, through detailed numerical simulations, verifies and clarifies the universal scaling behavior of the single electron box in the strong tunneling limit, providing a solid foundation for future research.