Religion and persecution

Umair Khalil,Laura Panza
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10887-023-09240-w
IF: 3.917
2024-03-07
Journal of Economic Growth
Abstract:This paper investigates the relationship between local religiosity and episodes of persecutions in Europe between 1100 and 1850. We introduce a novel proxy for measuring local religion: the cult of saints in early Western Christianity. Our findings show that cities with an established cult of a saint are 11% points more likely to engage in Jewish persecutions and witch trials. However, cities with more progressive gender norms, measured by the presence of a female saint cult, are less likely to persecute witches compared to male-only saint cities. Our baseline relationship persists after controlling for a range of city-level economic, geographic and institutional characteristics and after accounting for other major confounders. Suggestive evidence points towards two mechanisms behind the saints-persecution relationship: (i) changes in norms induced by longer exposure to Christianity; and (ii) proximity of religious groups due to congruence of religious festivities.
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the relationship between local religious piety and persecution events in Europe from the Middle Ages to the early modern period. Specifically, the authors introduce a new proxy variable - namely, the cult of saints in Western Christianity - to measure local religious piety and analyze how this piety has influenced the incidence of persecution of Jews and witch trials. The paper also examines the impact of gender norms on witch trials and finds that cities that worship female saints have fewer witch trials than those that only worship male saints. In addition, by controlling a series of economic, geographical and institutional characteristics at the city level and considering other major confounding factors, the study verifies the robustness of its baseline relationship. The paper proposes two possible mechanisms to explain the relationship between the cult of saints and persecution: one is the long - term exposure to changes in Christian norms; the other is the proximity of religious groups due to the consistency of religious festivals.