The Medieval Inquisition: Scale-free Networks and the Suppression of Heresy

Paul Ormerod,Andrew Roach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2004.03.020

2003-06-02

Abstract:Qualitative evidence suggests that heresy within the medieval Catholic Church had many of the characteristics of a scale-free network. From the perspective of the Church, heresy can be seen as a virus. The virus persisted for long periods of time, breaking out again even when the Church believed it to have been eradicated. A principal mechanism of heresy was through a small number of individuals with very large numbers of social contacts. Initial attempts by the Inquisition to suppress the virus by general persecution, or even mass slaughtering, of populations thought to harbour the "disease" failed. Gradually, however, the Inquisition learned about the nature of the social networks by which heresy both spread and persisted. Eventually, a policy of targeting key individuals was implemented, which proved to be much more successful.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How did the Catholic Church in the Middle Ages respond to the spread of heretical ideas regarded as "diseases"? Specifically, the author explored the spread patterns of heretical ideas in society and analyzed the effectiveness of different strategies adopted by the Church (especially the Inquisition) to suppress this spread.

### Main problems:
1. **Spread patterns of heretical ideas**:
- Heretical ideas within the Catholic Church in the Middle Ages exhibited characteristics similar to those of a scale - free network. The feature of a scale - free network is that a few nodes have a large number of connections, while most nodes have only a small number of connections. This enables heretical ideas to persist in society and be difficult to eradicate.
- From the perspective of the Church, heretical ideas can be metaphorically regarded as a virus, which can lurk in society for a long time and break out again after being considered eradicated.

2. **Failure of early suppression strategies**:
- In the early days, the Inquisition adopted extensive persecution policies, including massacres and random punishments, in an attempt to eliminate heretical ideas in this way. However, these strategies were not successful because they did not target the key nodes of the spread of heretical ideas (i.e., those with a large number of social connections).

3. **Gradual shift to more targeted strategies**:
- As time passed, the Inquisition gradually recognized the social network structure of the spread of heretical ideas and began to adopt more refined strategies. They learned to identify and target individuals with high connectivity in the social network for strikes. For example, by imprisoning, restricting freedom of movement, and marking these key figures, the spread channels of heretical ideas were effectively cut off.

### Conclusion:
- Through historical evidence, the paper shows that the Inquisition in the Middle Ages gradually learned how to deal with the characteristics of scale - free networks when dealing with heretical ideas. Although their methods were violent and oppressive, these strategies were indeed more effective than the early random persecutions.
- This shift not only reflects the Inquisition's understanding of the social network structure but also shows their strategic adjustment ability in the face of complex social problems.

In short, this paper explores how the Catholic Church in the Middle Ages responded to the spread of heretical ideas and reveals the practical application of scale - free networks in a historical context.