Abstract:We develop and defend the thesis that the Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics is a new theory of probability. The theory, like its classical counterpart, consists of an algebra of events, and the probability measures defined on it. The construction proceeds in the following steps: (a) Axioms for the algebra of events are introduced following Birkhoff and von Neumann. All axioms, except the one that expresses the uncertainty principle, are shared with the classical event space. The only models for the set of axioms are lattices of subspaces of inner product spaces over a field K. (b) Another axiom due to Soler forces K to be the field of real, or complex numbers, or the quaternions. We suggest a probabilistic reading of Soler's axiom. (c) Gleason's theorem fully characterizes the probability measures on the algebra of events, so that Born's rule is derived. (d) Gleason's theorem is equivalent to the existence of a certain finite set of rays, with a particular orthogonality graph (Wondergraph). Consequently, all aspects of quantum probability can be derived from rational probability assignments to finite "quantum gambles". We apply the approach to the analysis of entanglement, Bell inequalities, and the quantum theory of macroscopic objects. We also discuss the relation of the present approach to quantum logic, realism and truth, and the measurement problem.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Can the Hilbert - space formalism of quantum mechanics be regarded as a new probability theory?** Specifically, the author Itamar Pitowsky aims to demonstrate how the probability structure of quantum mechanics differs from the classical probability theory and how to explain various phenomena and paradoxes in quantum mechanics through this new perspective.
### Main steps and content of the paper:
1. **Axiomatization of event structure**:
- The author introduced an algebraic structure for describing quantum events. Most of these axioms are shared with the classical probability theory, but an axiom expressing the uncertainty principle is added.
- The final result derived from the axiom system is that all models that conform to these axioms are lattices of subspaces of inner product spaces over a field \( K \).
2. **Application of Soler's theorem**:
- Soler's axiom further restricts the field \( K \) so that it can only be the real number field, the complex number field, or the quaternion field.
- The author proposed a probability interpretation of Soler's axiom, thus connecting geometric concepts with quantum probability.
3. **The role of Gleason's theorem**:
- Gleason's theorem completely characterizes the probability measures defined on the event algebra and derives the Born rule.
- Gleason's theorem is equivalent to the existence of a specific finite - ray set (Wondergraph), which indicates that all aspects of quantum probability can be derived from the rational probability assignments in finite "quantum gambles".
4. **Explanation of entanglement and Bell's inequality**:
- The author explained the entanglement phenomenon observed in experiments, especially the violation of Bell's inequality, as a natural consequence of this probability structure.
5. **Hypothesis of macroscopic entanglement**:
- Even in the absence of decoherence, the author hypothesizes that macroscopic entanglement is difficult to observe and gives a precise conjecture.
6. **Measurement problem and realism**:
- The author discussed the relationship between this approach and quantum logic, realism, and truth, as well as its impact on the measurement problem.
### Summary:
The core objective of this paper is to re - interpret the Hilbert - space formalism of quantum mechanics as a new probability theory, explain various phenomena in quantum mechanics, such as entanglement and the violation of Bell's inequality, through this perspective, and explore its philosophical significance for reality and the measurement problem.