Freeze–Thaw Damage Degradation Model and Life Prediction of Air-Entrained Concrete in Multi-Year Permafrost Zone

Kai Zhang,Aojun Guo,Yonghui Yu,Bo Yang,Bentian Yu,Chao Xie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ma16247703
IF: 3.4
2023-12-18
Materials
Abstract:The Qinghai–Tibet Plateau is the main permafrost area in China. Concrete structures constructed on permafrost are affected by the early negative-temperature environment. In particular, the negative-temperature environment seriously affects the strength growth process and the frost resistance of concrete (FRC). Therefore, this study considered the influence of the gas content, water–binder ratio (w/b), age, and other factors on the strength variation law and FRC under −3 °C curing conditions. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) was used to analyze the pore structure of concrete before and after freeze–thaw cycles (FTCs). The results showed that the compressive strength of the concrete (CSC) under −3 °C curing was only 57.8–86.4% of that cured under standard conditions. The CSC under −3 °C curing showed an obvious age-lag phenomenon. The FRC under −3 °C curing was much lower than that under standard curing. The porosity of the concrete under −3 °C curing was greater, with a higher percentage of harmful and multi-harmful pores than that under standard curing. The concrete properties deteriorated primarily because curing at −3 °C hindered the hydration reaction compared with standard methods. This hindrance resulted in diminished hydration development, weakening the concrete’s structural integrity. Under both curing conditions, when the gas content was between 3.2% and 3.8%, the frost resistance was the best. This is because a gas content within this range effectively enhances the internal pore structure, therefore relieving the swelling pressure caused by FTCs. Based on the freeze–thaw damage (FTD) model proposed by previous authors, a new model for the CSC under −3 °C curing reaching that of the concrete under standard curing for 28 d was established in this study. This advanced model was capable of accurately assessing the FTD of concrete structures in permafrost regions. Finally, the life expectancy of concrete in Northwest China was predicted. The life of the concrete reached 46.9 years under standard curing, while the longest life of the concrete under −3 °C curing was only 12.9 years. Therefore, attention should be paid to constructing and curing concrete structures in cold environments.
materials science, multidisciplinary,chemistry, physical,physics, applied, condensed matter,metallurgy & metallurgical engineering
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in permafrost regions, the influence of the negative - temperature environment on the strength growth process and frost - resistance performance of air - entrained concrete (AEC). Specifically, the research focuses on the influence of factors such as gas content, water - to - binder ratio (w/b), and age on the strength change law and frost - resistance performance of concrete under the curing condition of −3°C, and analyzes the pore structure change of concrete before and after freeze - thaw cycles through nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). ### Research Background 1. **Environmental Characteristics of Permafrost Regions** - The Qinghai - Tibet Plateau is the main permafrost area in China. Concrete structures in permafrost regions are affected by the early low - temperature environment, especially the negative - temperature environment, which seriously interferes with the strength growth process and frost - resistance performance of concrete. - Permafrost can be divided into short - term permafrost, seasonal permafrost, and permafrost according to its freezing state and duration. The southern part of the Qinghai - Tibet Plateau and the northern part of Tibet are permafrost - developed areas. The underground permafrost layer in these areas is relatively thick, and the annual average ground temperature is between 0°C and −4°C. 2. **The Influence of Permafrost on Concrete** - Permafrost is a soil medium that is extremely sensitive to temperature and external factors. Factors such as concrete construction, heat, and hydration heat release cause changes in the physical field and upper limit of permafrost, affect the thermal stability of permafrost, and accelerate permafrost degradation. - Concrete structures built in permafrost regions are affected by temperature in the early stage, resulting in a decrease in strength and durability. Insufficient frost - resistance performance in the later stage is the main reason for the failure of concrete durability, which directly affects the stability and safety of bridge and culvert structures. ### Research Objectives 1. **Evaluate the Strength and Frost - Resistance Performance of Concrete under Negative - Temperature Curing Conditions** - Through experimental research, study the influence of different gas contents, water - to - binder ratios, and ages on the compressive strength and frost - resistance performance of concrete under the curing condition of −3°C. - Use nuclear magnetic resonance technology to analyze the pore structure change of concrete before and after freeze - thaw cycles and explore the relationship between pore structure and frost - resistance performance. 2. **Establish a Freeze - Thaw Damage Model** - Based on previous freeze - thaw damage models, propose a new freeze - thaw damage model suitable for concrete under the curing condition of −3°C to accurately evaluate the freeze - thaw damage of concrete structures in permafrost regions. - Predict the service life of concrete in the northwest region and provide guidance for concrete construction in cold regions. ### Main Research Contents 1. **Experimental Design** - Prepare concrete specimens with different water - to - binder ratios (0.38, 0.31, 0.24) and gas contents (0.8% - 9.6%). - The specimens are cured under −3°C and standard curing conditions respectively, and their compressive strength and freeze - thaw cycle performance are tested. 2. **Testing Methods** - **Compressive Strength Testing**: According to the GB/T 50081–2019 standard, use a pressure testing machine to test the compressive strength of 100 mm × 100 mm × 100 mm concrete test blocks at 7, 14, 28, 56, 84, and 180 days. - **Freeze - Thaw Cycle Testing**: According to the GB/T50082–2009 standard, use the rapid freeze - thaw method to test the frost - resistance performance of concrete and record the changes in mass loss rate (MLR) and dynamic elastic modulus (DME). - **Pore Structure Testing**: Use nuclear magnetic resonance technology to test the pore structure change of concrete before and after freeze - thaw cycles. ### Research Results 1. **The Influence of Gas Content on Compressive Strength** - An increase in gas content will lead to a decrease in the compressive strength of concrete. For example, the compressive strength of specimen A - 1 reaches 34.7 MPa after being cured at −3°C for 28 days, while the compressive strengths of A - 2, A - 3, and A - 4 are 95%, 81%, and 65% respectively. 2. **The Influence of Age on Compressive Strength** - The compressive strength of concrete increases with the increase of age. For example, the compressive strength of specimen A - 1 is 24.6 MPa after being cured at −3°C for 7 days and increases to 52.5 MPa at 180 days. 3. **The Influence of Water - to - Binder Ratio on Compressive Strength** - A lower water - to - binder ratio corresponds to a higher compressive strength. For example, the compressive strengths of specimens A - 1, B - 1, and C - 1 after being cured at −3°C for 28 days are 34.7 MPa, 42.5 MPa respectively.