Abstract:Purpose: Several new formalisms of Effective Atomic Number ( Z eff ) have emerged recently, deviating from the widely accepted Mayneord's definition. This comparative study aims to reexamine their theories, reveal their connections, and apply them to material differentiation on dual-energy computed tomography (DECT). Methods: The first part of this paper is an in-depth review of several highly cited Z eff formalisms. This part includes (1) refuting the claim in Taylor's study that the classic Mayneord's formalism was inaccurate, (2) showing that Mayneord's, Rutherford's, and Bourque's formalisms were equivalent, and (3) explaining the fundamental difference between Taylor's and Bourque's formalisms. The second part of this paper explains how we translated the theories into software implementation and added an open-source Z eff calculation engine to our free research software 3D Quantitative Imaging (3DQI). The work includes developing an interpolation method based on radial basis function to make Taylor's formalism applicable to DECT, and devising a table lookup method to generate Z eff map with high efficiency for all appropriate formalisms. Results: Comparing Bourque's and Taylor's formalisms for six common materials over 40 ∼ 100 keV energy range, it was found that Bourque's Z eff values had a weak energy dependence by 0.18% ∼ 3.10%, but for Taylor's results this variation increased by a factor of 10. Further comparison showed that at 61 keV, different formalisms fall into two categories-Bourque, Mayneord, Van Abbema (a derivative of Rutherford) for the first category, and Taylor and Manohara for the second. Formalisms within each category produced similar Z eff values. For a material consisting of two elements, the two categories of formalisms tended to show a greater discrepancy if the constituent elements had larger difference in Z . The developed Z eff calculation engine was successfully applied to kidney stone classification and colon electronic cleansing. Conclusions: We renewed the understanding of several popular Z eff formalisms: Contrary to the conclusion of Taylor's study, Mayneord's power-law formula is well grounded in theory; Bourque's formalism (based on the average electron microscopic cross-section) is considered numerically equivalent to Rutherford's, but with the advantage of being mathematically rigorous and physically meaningful; Taylor's formalism (based on the average atomic microscopic cross-section) is theoretically not suitable for DECT but a workaround still exists; Manohara's formalism should be used with caution due to a problem in its definition of electron cross-sections. The developed Z eff engine in the 3DQI software facilitated accurate and efficient Z eff estimate for various DECT applications.

Direct reconstruction of the effective atomic number of materials by the method of multi-energy radiography

Multi-Energy Radiography Against Terrorism. Theory and Experiments

A Reconstruction Method for Dual High-Energy CT With MeV X-Rays

Atomic number estimation of dual energy cargo radiographs: initial experimental results using a semiempirical transparency model

Atomic number estimation of dual energy cargo radiographs using a semiempirical transparency model

Iterative Reconstruction of the Electron Density and Effective Atomic Number using a Non-Linear Forward Model

A Practical Reconstruction Method for Dual Energy Computed Tomography

A comparative study of effective atomic number calculations for dual-energy CT

Multi-Energy and Fast-Convergence Iterative Reconstruction Algorithm for Organic Material Identification Using X-ray Computed Tomography

A Semiempirical Transparency Model for Dual Energy Cargo Radiography Applications

A new equivalent radiation source method for the reconstruction of nuclear radiation field

A Simulation Study on Basis Material Composition for Dual Energy Ct Imaging at High-Energy Level

A multi-material diagnosis method based on high-energy proton radiography

Atomic Number and Electron Density Measurement Using a Conventional X-ray Tube and a CdTe Detector

Development of a Technique for Determining the Optimal Number of Projections when Realizing the Method of Multiangle Scanning of an Ionizing Radiation Beam

Research and Selection of Prospective Materials for Activation Dosimetry of Intense Bremsstrahlung Radiation

Measurement of Atomic Number by MV X-Ray Scattering Spectra Analysis

Experimental demonstration of multiple monoenergetic gamma radiography for effective atomic number identification in cargo inspection

A Novel Decomposition Method For Dual-Energy Computed Tomography

Overlapped Materials Decomposition in High-Energy Dual-Energy X-ray System

Detection of High-Z Materials Using 7mev X-rays Scattering