The US 2000-2003 Market Descent: Clarifications

D. Sornette,W.-X. Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0305004

2003-05-01

Abstract:In a recent comment (Johansen A 2003 An alternative view, Quant. Finance 3: C6-C7, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/0302141" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0302141">cond-mat/0302141</a>), Anders Johansen has criticized our methodology and has questioned several of our results published in [Sornette D and Zhou W-X 2002 The US 2000-2002 market descent: how much longer and deeper? Quant. Finance 2: 468-81, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/0209065" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0209065">cond-mat/0209065</a>] and in our two consequent preprints [<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/0212010" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0212010">cond-mat/0212010</a>, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="physics/0301023" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0301023">physics/0301023</a>]. In the present reply, we clarify the issues on (i) the analogy between rupture and crash, (ii) the Landau expansion, ``double cosine'' and Weierstrass-type solutions, (iii) the symmetry between bubbles and anti-bubbles and universality, (iv) the condition of criticality, (v) the meaning of ``bullish anti-bubbles'', (vi) the absolute value of t_c-t, (vii) the fractal log-periodic power law patterns, (viii) the similarity between the Nikkei index in 1990-2000 and the S&P500 in 2000-2002 and (ix) the present status of our prediction.

Statistical Mechanics,Statistical Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to respond to Anders Johansen's criticism of their previous research methods and results, and to clarify some controversial points regarding the models of financial market bubbles and anti - bubbles. Specifically, the authors Didier Sornette and Wei - Xing Zhou explain in detail the following issues in the paper:

1. **Rupture Analogy and Critical Phenomena**:
- The authors emphasize that the collapse of the financial market should be regarded more as a finite - time singularity rather than a simple material rupture analogy. This singularity is caused by a positive - feedback mechanism and manifests as a critical phenomenon in the time domain.

2. **Landau Expansion, "Double - Cosine" Function and Weierstrass - type Solution**:
- In response to A. Johansen's criticism that the "double - cosine" function lacks a theoretical basis, the authors explain the form of the Weierstrass - type solution and point out that these solution forms provide a better theoretical foundation. The specific formula is:
\[
\ln[p(t)] = A + B\tau^m + \Re\left(\sum_{n = 1}^{N} C_n e^{i\psi_n\tau^{-s_n}}\right)
\]
where \(\tau = |t - t_c|\), \(s_n=-m + in\omega\), and \(\Re(\cdot)\) represents the operation of taking the real part. Different phases \(\psi_n\) reflect the information of the interaction mechanism among investors.

3. **Symmetry and Universality between Bubbles and Anti - Bubbles**:
- The authors believe that the symmetry between bubbles and anti - bubbles exists not only in description but also at the mechanism level. They point out that in the mathematical expression, this symmetry can be achieved by changing \(t_c - t\) to \(t - t_c\). At the same time, the authors emphasize that although in some cases the critical time \(t_c\) of bubbles and anti - bubbles is the same, it is usually different.

4. **Criticality Conditions**:
- The authors discuss whether giving up the constraint condition of \(m < 1\) means giving up the concept of criticality. They explain that even if \(m\geq1\), the equation still has singularity (that is, there are infinitely many log - periodic oscillations), so criticality still exists.

5. **"Bull - Market Anti - Bubble"**:
- The authors introduce the concept of "bull - market anti - bubble", which is a phenomenon where the price generally rises but is accompanied by decelerating log - periodic oscillations. This is different from the traditional bubble and anti - bubble situations, where the coefficient \(B > 0\).

6. **Absolute Value \(|t_c - t|\)**:
- The authors explain the rationality of using the absolute value \(|t_c - t|\) to determine the critical time \(t_c\). This method improves the robustness of fitting and avoids the arbitrariness of choosing the starting time.

7. **Fractal LPPL Pattern**:
- The authors mention that a smaller - scale anti - bubble structure is found inside a larger - scale anti - bubble, and this nested structure conforms to the Weierstrass - type solution predicted by the renormalization group model.

8. **Similarity between the Nikkei Index and the S&P 500 Index**:
- The authors emphasize the significant similarity between the Nikkei Index from 1990 - 2000 and the S&P 500 Index from 2000 - 2002, especially in terms of the competition of log - periodic frequencies.

9. **Prediction State**:
- Finally, the authors review their prediction performance. Although the prediction deviates from the actual data in some time periods, they insist that the overall trend prediction is valid.

In general, this paper aims to clarify and defend the theoretical framework of financial market bubbles and anti - bubbles previously proposed by the authors and respond to the questions of critics.