Characterization of catastrophic instabilities: Market crashes as paradigm

Anirban Chakraborti,Kiran Sharma,Hirdesh K. Pharasi,Sourish Das,Rakesh Chatterjee,Thomas H. Seligman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1801.07213

2018-01-23

Abstract:Catastrophic events, though rare, do occur and when they occur, they have devastating effects. It is, therefore, of utmost importance to understand the complexity of the underlying dynamics and signatures of catastrophic events, such as market crashes. For deeper understanding, we choose the US and Japanese markets from 1985 onward, and study the evolution of the cross-correlation structures of stock return matrices and their eigenspectra over different short time-intervals or "epochs". A slight non-linear distortion is applied to the correlation matrix computed for any epoch, leading to the emerging spectrum of eigenvalues. The statistical properties of the emerging spectrum display: (i) the shape of the emerging spectrum reflects the market instability, (ii) the smallest eigenvalue may be able to statistically distinguish the nature of a market turbulence or crisis -- internal instability or external shock, and (iii) the time-lagged smallest eigenvalue has a statistically significant correlation with the mean market cross-correlation. The smallest eigenvalue seems to indicate that the financial market has become more turbulent in a similar way as the mean does. Yet we show features of the smallest eigenvalue of the emerging spectrum that distinguish different types of market instabilities related to internal or external causes. Based on the paradigmatic character of financial time series for other complex systems, the capacity of the emerging spectrum to understand the nature of instability may be a new feature, which can be broadly applied.

General Finance,Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the complex dynamics and characteristics of catastrophic events (such as market crashes) in financial markets. Specifically, the author chooses to study the situations in the US and Japanese markets since 1985. By analyzing the cross - correlation structure of the stock return matrix and the evolution of its characteristic spectrum within different short - time intervals or "periods", the author explores the signs of market instability. The main objectives of the paper include:

1. **Characteristics of market instability**: To study how the shape of the emerging characteristic spectrum reflects market instability.
2. **Distinguishing types of market turbulence**: To explore whether the minimum eigenvalue can statistically distinguish the nature of market turbulence or crisis - internal instability or external shock.
3. **Relationship between the minimum eigenvalue and the average cross - correlation in the market**: To analyze the statistically significant correlation between the minimum eigenvalue lagged by one day and the average cross - correlation in the market.

### Specific problem description

- **Characteristics of market instability**:
- The research finds that the shape of the emerging characteristic spectrum can reflect market instability. For example, when the market is in a normal state, the emerging characteristic spectrum is semicircular; while when the market is in a critical state (i.e., highly turbulent), the emerging characteristic spectrum follows a Lorentz distribution and there are very strong correlations.

- **Distinguishing types of market turbulence**:
- The minimum eigenvalue can be used to statistically distinguish the nature of market turbulence or crisis. For example, in a market crash caused by an internal reaction, the minimum eigenvalue usually becomes an outlier, while it does not in a market crash caused by an external shock.

- **Relationship between the minimum eigenvalue and the average cross - correlation in the market**:
- Through a linear regression model, the research finds that there is a statistically significant correlation between the minimum eigenvalue lagged by one day and the average cross - correlation in the market. This indicates that the minimum eigenvalue can be used as a signal of market turbulence.

### Method overview

- **Data sources**: Used the time series of adjusted closing prices of stocks in the US (S&P 500 index) and Japan (Nikkei 225 index) from 1985 to 2016.
- **Cross - correlation matrix**: Constructed the time series of stock returns and calculated the cross - correlation matrices within different time periods.
- **Emerging characteristic spectrum**: Applied a non - linear distortion to the cross - correlation matrix of each period to generate the emerging characteristic spectrum.
- **Statistical analysis**: Analyzed the statistical properties of the emerging characteristic spectrum, especially the behavior of the minimum eigenvalue, through statistical methods (such as t - test, linear regression model).

### Conclusion

By analyzing the shape of the emerging characteristic spectrum and the behavior of the minimum eigenvalue, the paper successfully reveals some important characteristics of market instability. These findings not only help to understand the complex dynamics of financial markets, but may also provide a new research perspective for catastrophic events in other complex systems.