Endogenous Crashes as Phase Transitions

Revant Nayar,Minhajul Islam

2024-08-13

Abstract:This paper explores the mechanisms behind extreme financial events, specifically market crashes, by employing the theoretical framework of phase transitions. We focus on endogenous crashes, driven by internal market dynamics, and model these events as first-order phase transitions critical, stochastic, and dynamic. Through a comparative analysis of early warning signals associated with each type of transition, we demonstrate that dynamic phase transitions (DPT) offer a more accurate representation of market crashes than critical (CPT) or stochastic phase transitions (SPT). Unlike existing models, such as the Log-Periodic Power Law (LPPL) model, which often suffers from overfitting and false positives, our approach grounded in DPT provides a more robust prediction framework. Empirical findings, based on an analysis of S&P 500 stocks from 2019 to 2024, reveal significant trends in volatility and anomalous dimensions before crashes, supporting the superiority of the DPT model. This work contributes to a deeper understanding of the predictive signals preceding market crashes and offers a novel perspective on their underlying dynamics.

Mathematical Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and predict extreme events in financial markets, especially market crashes. Traditional models often regard market crashes as random anomalies or results driven by external shocks. However, this paper presents a new perspective, believing that many market crashes are endogenous, that is, caused by internal market dynamics.

### Specific Problems and Solutions

1. **Endogenous Crash Mechanisms**:
- The paper explores using phase transition theory to explain the crash mechanisms driven by internal market dynamics.
- Model market crashes as first - order phase transitions, which are divided into three types: Critical Phase Transitions (CPT), Stochastic Phase Transitions (SPT), and Dynamic Phase Transitions (DPT).

2. **Early Warning Signals**:
- Compare the early warning signals of these three phase transition types and evaluate their predictive capabilities.
- Through empirical analysis of S&P 500 stock data (from 2019 to 2024), study the changing trends of volatility, skewness, and fractal dimension.

3. **Limitations of Existing Models**:
- Compare with the widely - used Log - Periodic Power Law (LPPL) model, and point out its problems of over - fitting and high false - positive rate.
- Propose a new method based on Dynamic Phase Transitions (DPT) to provide a more robust prediction framework.

### Main Contributions

- **Theoretical Contribution**: By introducing phase transition theory, it provides a new theoretical framework for understanding market crashes.
- **Empirical Contribution**: Use S&P 500 data for empirical analysis to verify the superiority of dynamic phase transitions in predicting market crashes.
- **Practical Application**: Provide practical tools for early detection and risk management, which help market participants better prepare for and mitigate the impact of crashes.

### Conclusion

The main conclusion of the paper is that the Dynamic Phase Transitions (DPT) model is more accurate and robust in predicting market crashes than Critical Phase Transitions (CPT), Stochastic Phase Transitions (SPT), and the LPPL model. Market crashes are not just random or exogenously - driven events, but endogenous processes that can be predicted by analyzing market indicators.

### Summary of Mathematical Formulas

1. **Log - Periodic Power Law (LPPL) Model**:
\[
h(t)\propto|t - t_c|^{\alpha + i\beta}
\]
\[
h(t)=\alpha(t_c - t)^{m - 1}(1+\beta\cos(\omega\ln(t_c - t)-\phi))
\]
\[
\ln(p(t))=A + B(t_c - t)^m+C(t - t_c)^m\cos(\omega\ln(t_c - t)-\phi)
\]

2. **Observations of Dynamic Phase Transitions**:
\[
\Delta(t,\tau)=K-\frac{\ln(G(t,\tau))}{\ln\tau}
\]
\[
\langle X(t)^n\rangle=A_n|t|^{\Delta_n},\quad\text{where}\quad\Delta_n = K_n+\frac{\ln\langle X(t)^n\rangle}{\ln|t|}
\]

These formulas show how to use mathematical models to describe and predict different stages and characteristics of market crashes.