A. Anthore,F. Pierre,H. Pothier,D. Esteve,M.-H. Devoret
Abstract:We have measured in a copper wire the energy exchange rate between quasiparticles as a function of the applied magnetic field. We find that the effective electron-electron interaction is strongly modified by the magnetic field, suggesting that magnetic impurities play a role on the interaction processes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **The influence of magnetic field on the effective electron - electron interaction in copper wires**. Specifically, the researchers measured the energy exchange rate between quasiparticles in copper wires under different external magnetic fields to explore whether magnetic impurities play a role in these interaction processes.
### Research Background
In metal wires, electron - electron interactions can lead to quasi - elastic scattering and inelastic scattering. Quasi - elastic scattering will change the phase coherence time of electrons, while inelastic scattering will redistribute energy among electrons. Recent experiments have shown that these properties may depend on the specific situation of the sample. In addition, the saturation phenomenon of the phase coherence time \( \tau_\phi \) at low temperatures is related to the abnormal dependence of the function \( K(\epsilon) \) related to the exchange energy \( \epsilon \).
### Comparison between Theoretical Predictions and Experimental Results
For pure Coulomb interactions, theoretical predictions are \( \tau_\phi \propto T^{-2/3} \) and \( K(\epsilon) \propto \epsilon^{-3/2} \), and these predictions have been verified in silver wires. However, in copper wires, what is observed is that \( \tau_\phi \) saturates and \( K(\epsilon) \propto \epsilon^{-2} \). In gold wires containing a large amount of magnetic impurities (such as iron), a similar behavior has also been found, and the pre - factor of \( K(\epsilon) \) is particularly large.
### The Role of Magnetic Impurities
Theoretically, the scattering of magnetic impurities not only limits the phase coherence time but also provides another channel for energy exchange between quasiparticles. In order to verify whether magnetic impurities play a role in copper wires, the researchers measured the influence of magnetic field on the energy exchange rate.
### Experimental Method
The experiment determines the energy exchange rate by measuring the local electron energy distribution function \( f(x, E) \) in copper wires. The experimental setup includes a mesoscopic metal wire between two large electrodes, forming a Landauer reservoir. By adjusting the voltage \( U \) and magnetic field \( B \), the researchers can observe the changes in the distribution function under different conditions.
### Main Findings
1. **Changes in the Distribution Function**: In the absence of a magnetic field, the distribution function \( f(E) \) only depends on \( E/eU \). However, when a magnetic field exists, this scaling relationship no longer holds, and the change in \( f(E) \) is related to the voltage and magnetic field intensity.
2. **Dependence of the Energy Exchange Rate**: By fitting the experimental data, the researchers found that the energy exchange rate \( \gamma(U, B) \) shows non - monotonic behavior with the change of magnetic field and bias voltage. In particular, near \( B\approx eU / 4.3\mu_B \), the interaction intensity reaches a maximum and then decreases again.
### Conclusion
The research results show that the abnormal energy exchange rate between quasiparticles in copper wires strongly depends on the magnetic field. The influence of magnetic field and bias voltage on the interaction intensity is qualitatively consistent with the interaction mediated by magnetic impurities. Although the specific properties of magnetic impurities are still unclear, the measurement of the phase coherence time indicates that copper oxide may play a role in it.
### Formula Summary
- The relationship between phase coherence time and temperature: \[ \tau_\phi \propto T^{-2/3} \]
- The form of the energy exchange function \( K(\epsilon) \):
- For pure Coulomb interactions: \[ K(\epsilon) \propto \epsilon^{-3/2} \]
- In copper wires: \[ K(\epsilon) \propto \epsilon^{-2} \]
These formulas help to explain the phenomena observed in the experiment and provide a theoretical basis for understanding the role of magnetic impurities in electron interactions in copper wires.