Abstract:We study the perturbative unitarity of noncommutative scalar field theories. Field theories with space-time noncommutativity do not have a unitary S-matrix. Field theories with only space noncommutativity are perturbatively unitary. This can be understood from string theory, since space noncommutative field theories describe a low energy limit of string theory in a background magnetic field. On the other hand, there is no regime in which space-time noncommutative field theory is an appropriate description of string theory. Whenever space-time noncommutative field theory becomes relevant massive open string states cannot be neglected.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the unitarity problem in non - commutative space - time field theory. Specifically, the author studied the unitarity of scalar field theory with space - time non - commutativity under perturbation theory. The main focuses of the paper are as follows:
1. **The influence of space - time non - commutativity on unitarity**: The paper explored whether the scalar field theory maintains unitarity when there is space - time non - commutativity (i.e., \(\theta_{0i}\neq0\)). By calculating the scattering amplitude of one - loop diagrams, the author found that space - time non - commutativity would cause Feynman diagrams not to satisfy the usual cutting rules, resulting in the S - matrix not satisfying the unitarity condition.
2. **The case of pure spatial non - commutativity**: The paper also studied the case where there is only spatial non - commutativity (i.e., \(\theta_{0i} = 0\)), and found that in this case, the scalar field theory is unitary. This can be understood through the low - energy limit in string theory, where pure spatial non - commutativity describes string theory in the background magnetic field.
3. **The explanation from string theory**: The author explained these results from the perspective of string theory. The field theory of pure spatial non - commutativity can be regarded as an effective description of string theory in the low - energy limit and is therefore unitary. However, the field theory of space - time non - commutativity cannot accurately describe string theory in any case because in this case, a large number of open - string states cannot be ignored.
### Main conclusions
- **Space - time non - commutativity**: When \(\theta_{0i}\neq0\), the scalar field theory does not satisfy the unitarity condition at the one - loop level, manifested as Feynman diagrams not satisfying the cutting rules.
- **Pure spatial non - commutativity**: When \(\theta_{0i} = 0\), the scalar field theory is unitary at the one - loop level, and Feynman diagrams satisfy the cutting rules.
- **From the perspective of string theory**: The pure spatial non - commutativity field theory can be naturally derived from the low - energy limit in string theory, while the space - time non - commutativity field theory cannot find a consistent description in string theory.
### Formula summary
- **Non - commutative product**:
\[
\phi_1(x)\star\phi_2(x)=e^{i\frac{\theta^{\mu\nu}}{2}\partial_{\alpha^\mu}\partial_{\beta^\nu}}\phi_1(x + \alpha)\phi_2(x + \beta)\big|_{\alpha=\beta = 0}
\]
- **Space - time uncertainty relation**:
\[
\Delta x^\mu\Delta x^\nu\geq\frac{1}{2}|\theta^{\mu\nu}|
\]
- **Inner product**:
\[
p\circ p=-p_\mu\theta^2_{\mu\nu}p_\nu
\]
- **Optical theorem**:
\[
2\mathrm{Im}M_{ab}=\sum_nM_{an}M_{nb}
\]
- **Amplitude of one - loop diagrams**:
\[
iM=\frac{\lambda^2}{2}\int\frac{d^Dl}{(2\pi)^D}(1 + \cos(p\wedge l))\frac{1}{l^2 - m^2 + i\epsilon}\frac{1}{(l + p)^2 - m^2 + i\epsilon}
\]
- **Right side of the cutting rule**:
\[
\sum|M|^2=\frac{\lambda^2}{2}\frac{1}{(2\pi)^{D - 2}}\int\frac{d^{D - 1}k}{2k_0}\frac{d^{D - 1}q}{2q_0}\delta^D(p - k - q)(1 + \cos(p\wedge k))
\]
Through these formulas and analysis, the author reached the conclusion about the unitarity of non - commutative field theory.