Abstract:Abstract Students in upper secondary education encounter difficulties in applying mathematics in physics. To improve our understanding of these difficulties, we examined symbol sense behavior of six grade 10 physics students solving algebraic physic problems. Our data confirmed that students did indeed struggle to apply algebra to physics, mainly because they lacked both sufficient symbol sense behavior and basic algebraic skills. They used ad hoc strategies instead of correct, systematic rule-based procedures involving insight. These ad hoc strategies included the cross-multiplication, the numbering, and the permutation strategy. They worked only for basic formulas containing few variables. In problems with more variables, students got stuck. The latter two strategies substitute numbers for variables. The permutation strategy randomly checks several permutations to guess which one is correct. The numbering strategy substitutes numbers to check algebraic manipulations. Our results indicate insufficient focus on conceptual understanding of algebra in some mathematics textbooks, leading to reliance on poorly understood ad hoc strategies. Effective teaching of algebraic skills should not focus on either basic algebraic skills or on symbol sense behavior. Instead, both aspects should be taught in an integrated manner. Our operationalization of symbol sense behavior turned out to be very useful for analysis. In contrast to earlier qualitative studies, it provided us the opportunity to measure symbol sense behavior quantitatively. This operationalization should also be applicable to other science subjects. Furthermore, we discussed some implications of our results for curricula, teachers, science teacher educators, and textbook publishers aiming at successful application of mathematics in physics.

Symbol sense with a symbolic-graphical system: a story in three rounds

Search for Symbol Sense Behavior: Students in Upper Secondary Education Solving Algebraic Physics Problems

A Symbolic Computing Perspective on Software Systems

Solving Geometry Problems Using a Combination of Symbolic and Numerical Reasoning

Symbol sense characteristics for designing mathematics tasks

Impact of Steps, Instruction, and Motivation on Learning Symbolic Reasoning Using an Online Tool

Symbolic Manipulators Affect Mathematical Mindsets

Unpacking Symbolic Equations in Introductory Physics

Symbolic representation in early years learning: The acquisition of complex notions

Learning Is Moving in New Ways: The Ecological Dynamics of Mathematics Education

Symbolic Narratives and the Role of Meaning: Encountering Technology in South African Primary Education

Iconic Mathematics: Math Designed to Suit the Mind

Using Figurate Numbers in Elementary Number Theory - Discussing a 'Useful' Heuristic From the Perspectives of Semiotics and Cognitive Psychology

Sustainability Development in Mathematics Education—A Case Study of What Kind of Meanings Do Prospective Class Teachers Find for the Mathematical Symbol “23”?

Symbolic representation of letters and numbers

Symbol Emergence in Cognitive Developmental Systems: A Survey

The role of symbols in mathematical communication: the case of the limit notation

SymCog: An open-source toolkit for assessing human symbolic cognition

A field-theory motivated approach to symbolic computer algebra

Introduction to the Symbolic Integration System

Variables versus numbers: Effects of symbols and algebraic knowledge on students’ problem-solving strategies