Abstract:Abstract Students in upper secondary education encounter difficulties in applying mathematics in physics. To improve our understanding of these difficulties, we examined symbol sense behavior of six grade 10 physics students solving algebraic physic problems. Our data confirmed that students did indeed struggle to apply algebra to physics, mainly because they lacked both sufficient symbol sense behavior and basic algebraic skills. They used ad hoc strategies instead of correct, systematic rule-based procedures involving insight. These ad hoc strategies included the cross-multiplication, the numbering, and the permutation strategy. They worked only for basic formulas containing few variables. In problems with more variables, students got stuck. The latter two strategies substitute numbers for variables. The permutation strategy randomly checks several permutations to guess which one is correct. The numbering strategy substitutes numbers to check algebraic manipulations. Our results indicate insufficient focus on conceptual understanding of algebra in some mathematics textbooks, leading to reliance on poorly understood ad hoc strategies. Effective teaching of algebraic skills should not focus on either basic algebraic skills or on symbol sense behavior. Instead, both aspects should be taught in an integrated manner. Our operationalization of symbol sense behavior turned out to be very useful for analysis. In contrast to earlier qualitative studies, it provided us the opportunity to measure symbol sense behavior quantitatively. This operationalization should also be applicable to other science subjects. Furthermore, we discussed some implications of our results for curricula, teachers, science teacher educators, and textbook publishers aiming at successful application of mathematics in physics.

Variables versus numbers: Effects of symbols and algebraic knowledge on students’ problem-solving strategies

From here to there! Elementary: a game-based approach to developing number sense and early algebraic understanding

The impact of various teaching methods on the knowledge of students of different genders: The case of mathematics word problems abstract

The Impacts of Three Educational Technologies on Algebraic Understanding in the Context of COVID-19

Uncovering the interplay between drawings, mental representations, and arithmetic problem-solving strategies in children and adults

Rational number representation, math anxiety, and algebra performance in college students

Effects of example variability and prior knowledge in how students learn to solve equations

Teaching mathematics by comparison: Analog visibility as a double-edged sword.

Exploration of Students' Epistemological Obstacles in Understanding the Concept of Variables and Expressions

Characteristics of students’ mathematical representation in solving algebraic thinking problems

Every word problem has a solution—The social rationality of mathematical modeling in schools

Generalizing actions with the subtraction-compensation property: primary students' algebraic thinking with tasks involving vertical towers of blocks

Algebraic Thinking in Arithmetic:Quasi ?variable Expressions

The cost of multiple representations: Learning number symbols with abstract and concrete representations.

The Models and Influencing Factors of Visualization Representations for Algebra Story Problems

Comparing the Effectiveness of Virtual and Concrete Manipulatives to Teach Algebra to Secondary Students With Learning Disabilities

Search for Symbol Sense Behavior: Students in Upper Secondary Education Solving Algebraic Physics Problems

Differential cognitive correlates in processing symbolic and situational mathematics

Students' Responses To Different Representations Of A Vector Addition Question

The Effects of Presenting Multidigit Mathematics Problems in a Realistic Context on Sixth Graders' Problem Solving

On the Different Types of Representations of Elementary Students' Arithmatic Word Problems and Their Effects Upon Word Problem Solving