What did the abbacus teachers really do when they (sometimes) ended up doing mathematics?
JENS HØYRUP
2007-01-01
Abstract:Abstract Italian fourteenth- and fifteenth-century abbacus,algebra presents us with a number,of deviations from what,we,would,consider normal,(or proper) mathematical,behaviour: the invention,of completely,false algebraic rules for the solution of cubic and quartic equations, and of rules that pretend to be generally valid but in fact only hold in very special cases; and (in modern,terms) an attempt to expand,the multiplicative semi-group of non-negative,algebraic powers,into a complete,group,by treating roots as negative powers. In both cases, the authors of the fallacies must have known they were cheating. Certain abbacus writers seem to have discovered, however, that something was wrong, and devised alternative approaches to the cubics and quartics, and developed safeguards against the latter misconception. The paper analyses both phenomena, and correlates them with the general norm system,of abbacus,mathematics,as this can be extracted from the more,elementary,level of the abbacus,treatises. Contents