Assistive Robotics Needs for Older Care: Using Authentic Citations to Bridge the Gap between Understanding Older Persons' Needs and Defining Solutions

Louise Veling,Rudi Villing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12369-024-01118-0

IF: 3.802

2024-03-15

International Journal of Social Robotics

Abstract:Developing an authentic understanding of potential users' needs and translating these into usable categories as an input to research and development is an open problem. It is generally accepted that genuine knowledge of user needs is essential for the creation of any new technology. For assistive robots, however, this knowledge is even more important for two key reasons. First, because the form and function of these technologies is still in the process of negotiation, and second, because assistive robots are ultimately intended for a vulnerable population. In this paper, we describe a number of existing strategies to address this challenge and discuss some of their shortcomings, including a loss of data richness and context, the stereotyping of users and a lack of transparency and traceability. The primary contribution of this paper is a novel Authentic Citations process for capturing needs which aims to address these shortcomings. This process involves a thematic analysis of complex qualitative data to derive robotics needs for older people, which emphasises the retention of the original situated description, or 'authentic citation', for ongoing sensitising and grounding at all stages of the research and development cycle, and by various stakeholders. The Authentic Citations process adds additional rigour to a process that can be tacit and opaque and can be used by robotics researchers to analyse and translate qualitative research into usable categories. An additional contribution of this paper is an initial outline of a taxonomy of assistive robotics needs for older people, which contributes to improving the understanding of the user as a situated and complex person and can be used as an input to design.

robotics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: how to more realistically and meticulously understand the actual needs of the elderly when developing assistive robotics technology, and translate these needs into actionable research and development requirements. Specifically, the paper points out that current designs of assistive robots often rely on stereotypes and generalized assumptions about the needs of the elderly, lacking an in-depth understanding of the users' actual life contexts. This leads to several issues in technology design, such as the loss of data richness and contextual information, the formation of user stereotypes, and a lack of transparency and traceability.

To address these issues, the paper proposes a new "Authentic Citations" process, which captures the needs of the elderly through qualitative data analysis and retains the original contextual descriptions. This ensures sensitivity and foundational understanding of user needs at all stages of research and development. This method aims to increase the rigor and transparency of the interpretation and translation process, thereby improving the quality and applicability of technology design.