Addressing Potential Pitfalls of SAR Assistance on the Aging Population

Emilyann Nault,Ronnie Smith,Lynne Baillie

2023-03-24

Abstract:In the field of Human Robot Interaction (HRI), socially assistive robots are being investigated to see if they can help combat challenges that can come with aging by providing different forms of support to older adults. As a result, it is imperative that the HRI community are aware of the potential pitfalls that can occur such as over-attachment, over-reliance, and increased isolation. This position paper argues designers should (a) avoid pitfalls that can lead to a negative impact on decline, and (b) leverage SAR decision making to avoid the pitfalls while attaining the benefits of this technology. Finally, we describe the concept for a framework as a starting point for addressing the concerns raised in this paper.

Robotics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application and potential issues of Socially Assistive Robots (SARs) among the elderly population. Specifically, the paper points out the following:

1. **Over-attachment**: Elderly individuals may develop excessive emotional attachment to SARs, which could lead to emotional over-reliance on the robots, thereby affecting their social interactions with real people. For example, some elderly individuals might be reluctant to go out because they worry that the robot will "miss" them, which in turn increases their sense of loneliness.

2. **Over-reliance**: Although SARs are designed to help elderly individuals maintain their independence through daily activity support, cognitive training, and other means, if not properly designed, these robots might automate many tasks, leading to further deterioration of the elderly's physical or cognitive functions. To avoid this, researchers suggest allowing users to personalize the robot's functions according to their needs and ensuring that users always have ultimate control.

3. **Increased isolation**: SARs might unintentionally exacerbate social isolation among the elderly. For instance, some elderly individuals might be reluctant to invite others to their homes because they worry that using a robot will be seen as a sign that they "need care." Additionally, if elderly individuals rely too much on the companionship provided by robots, it might reduce their opportunities for interaction with other people.

To address these issues, the paper proposes a conceptual framework aimed at guiding SAR designers to consider these potential risks during the development process and take corresponding measures to maximize the benefits of the technology while avoiding negative impacts. Overall, the paper emphasizes the need for caution in designing SARs to ensure that these technologies can truly have a positive effect rather than backfire.