Abstract:Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, Ahead of Print. Self-organisation in territories leads to the emergence of patterns in urban systems that shape the interactions and dependencies between cities, resulting in a hierarchical organisation. Governance follows a hierarchical structure as well, breaking the territory into smaller units for its management. The possible mismatch between these two organisations may lead to a range of problems, ranging from inefficiencies to insufficient and uneven distribution of resources. This paper seeks to develop a methodology to explore and quantify the correspondence between the hierarchical organisation given by the structure of governance and that given by the structure of the urban systems being governed, where Chile is used as a case study. The urban hierarchical structure is defined according to the connectivity of the system given by the road network. This is extracted through a clustering algorithm defined as a percolation process on the Chilean street network, giving rise to urban clusters at different scales. These are then compared to the spatial scales of the politico-administrative system. This is achieved by using measures of pair-wise distance similarity on the dendrograms, such as the cophenetic distance, by looking at the different clustering membership using Jaccard similarity and by analysing the topological diversity defined as the structural entropy. The results show that the urban sub-national structures present high heterogeneity, while the administrative system is highly homogeneous, replicating the same structure of organisation across the national territory. Such contrasting organisational structures present administrative challenges that can give rise to poor decision-making processes and mismanagement, in addition to impairing the efficient functioning of the systems themselves. Our results can help address these challenges, informing how to rebalance such mismatches through planning and political strategies that consider the complex interdependencies of territories across scales.

Decentralization as Organizing Principle of Emergent Urban Structures

The Emergence of Bologna and its Future Consequences. Decentralization as Cohesion Catalyst in Guild Dominated Urban Networks

Reconstructing Bologna. The City as an Emergent Computational System - A Study in the Complexity of Urban Structures. Part I: The Basic Idea and Fundamental Concepts

Microeconomic Foundations of Decentralised Organisations

On Principles of Emergent Organization

Self-organizing Networks of Cities: Scaling Laws, Symmetry, Complexity and Optimization

Reflections on organization, emergence, and control in sociotechnical systems

Is the World Local or Nonlocal? Towards an Emergent Quantum Mechanics in the 21st Century

Reinterpreting Central Place Networks Using Ideas from Fractals and Self-Organized Criticality

Structure Entropy, Self-Organization, and Power Laws in Urban Street Networks: Evidence for Alexander's Ideas

The Impact of Decentralization on the Development of Civil Society in the Context of the Philosophy of Reason

The Concept of Decentralization Through Time and Disciplines: A Quantitative Exploration

On Scaling Functionality in Urban Form

Ten Questions about Emergence

On structure and organization: an organizing principle

A Categorical Framework for Quantifying Emergent Effects in Network Topology

Self-Organised Criticality and Emergent Hyperbolic Networks -- Blueprint for Complexity in Social Dynamics

Decentralization in Digital Societies -- A Design Paradox

The scalar mismatch of regional governance: A comparative analysis of hierarchical structures