What's worse, communism or carbon? Using the Transitions Delphi approach to identify viable interventions for the Estonian energy transition

Anna-Kati Pahker,Margit Keller,Erkki Karo,Triin Vihalemm,Mihkel Solvak,Kati Orru,Erki Tammiksaar,Kadri Ukrainski,Martin Noorkõiv
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2024.103421
IF: 8.514
2024-01-21
Energy Research & Social Science
Abstract:A new framework identifying six intervention points for accelerating transitions responds to the calls for the study of the multi-system dynamics and the design of corresponding policy interventions to support sustainability transitions. Applying the framework, however, requires novel methodological and empirical approaches in research. This paper presents the results from a research project that uses the framework and employs a novel methodological approach to identify combinations of preferred interventions for steering the Estonian energy transition. Because the number of potential interventions is extensive and their assessment requires diverse expertise, we have pioneered the Transitions Delphi approach, tailored specifically for socio-technical transitions. Using the method to analyze Estonian energy transition, we show that there are coherent intervention bundles that different expert groups prefer, which reflect envisioned transition pathways: system optimization, partial system redesign, and system change. However, this preference is not dictated by domain expertise but by the expert's desired future energy system configuration and energy mix. We additionally find stick measures more divisive than carrots and sermons and general (over-)enthusiasm for the feasibility of non-technological interventions and technocratic styles of policymaking. Overall, our approach highlights the likely directions and key uncertainties of transition pathways. While there are limitations to our study, the results demonstrate that our design and implementation of the Transitions Delphi method is a suitable starting point for studying multi-system and multi-level dynamics to accelerate transitions. Our findings could be used in a multi-stage follow-up research combining stakeholder and scenario workshops and quantitative modelling of energy scenarios.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?