Abstract:Green transition is in the core of the European policy agenda to achieve the ambitious goal of climate neutrality following the launch of the European Green Deal. The cornerstone of the new growth strategy of Europe is resource efficiency which focuses on shifting to a more sustainable production paradigm by conserving scarce resources and by prioritizing enhanced environmental performance. Scattered efforts to investigate the drivers of resource efficiency measures have shed light on the key drivers, however, those consider resource efficiency measures in isolation neglecting for feedback loops influencing green transition. Therefore, we develop a conceptual framework to study green transition as a system of resource efficiency measures affected by feedback loops, path dependence, green technologies, and green policy tools. We mobilize the analysis by devising a unique balanced panel covering the EU-28 from 2010 through 2019, including policy efforts paving the way for green transition. Econometric results based on a system of fractional probit models, indicate that resource efficiency measures are intertwined via feedback loops, especially in the case of environmental efficiency. Green technologies affect green transition, however, rebound effects emerge in the case of energy efficiency. Past performance affects current levels pushing towards divergence. Evidence suggests that green taxation fosters energy efficiency whereas hinders environmental efficiency. The asymmetric operation of feedback loops and green taxation on energy and environmental efficiency highlights that horizontal policies hinder rather than foster green transition. This study contributes to SDGs 7, 12, 13 and 16.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to explore whether the feedback loop between energy efficiency and environmental efficiency promotes the green transition in Europe and analyzes the role of eco-innovation, renewable energy, and green taxes in this process.
### Abstract and Main Content
This paper focuses on the core issues of the European green transition. The European Green Deal sets ambitious goals for achieving climate neutrality, making resource efficiency the core of the new growth strategy, with an emphasis on shifting to more sustainable production models by saving scarce resources and improving environmental performance. Although previous studies have revealed some factors that promote resource efficiency, these studies often view resource efficiency measures in isolation, ignoring the feedback loops that affect the green transition.
Therefore, this paper proposes a conceptual framework that views the green transition as a system composed of resource efficiency measures and considers the impact of feedback loops, path dependency, green technology, and green policy tools. The study uses a unique panel dataset of 28 EU countries from 2010 to 2019 for analysis. The econometric results based on the fractional Probit model show that there are interacting feedback loops between resource efficiency measures, especially in terms of environmental efficiency. Green technology has a positive impact on the green transition but shows a rebound effect in terms of energy efficiency. Past performance affects current levels, driving differentiated trends. Evidence suggests that green taxes promote energy efficiency but hinder environmental efficiency. The asymmetric operation of feedback loops and green taxes on energy and environmental efficiency indicates that horizontal policies actually hinder rather than promote the green transition.
This paper contributes to Sustainable Development Goals 7, 12, 13, and 16.
### Research Hypotheses
1. **Energy and environmental efficiency promote the green transition through positive feedback loops**.
2. **Energy and environmental efficiency exhibit path-dependent patterns that hinder the green transition**.
3. **Green technology promotes the green transition**.
4. **Green taxes do not inhibit the green transition**.
### Data and Methods
The study utilizes data from multiple public databases, covering data from 28 EU countries from 2010 to 2019. Specific variables include:
- **Output**: Gross Domestic Product (GDP), CO2 emissions.
- **Input**: Capital stock, labor, energy usage.
- **Green Technology**: Eco-innovation index, proportion of renewable energy usage.
- **Green Taxes**: Tax revenue related to energy and climate change.
- **Production Environment Characteristics**: Global Competitiveness Index, Economic Freedom Index, proportion of GDP from agriculture, manufacturing, and service sectors.
### Conclusion
The study finds that there is an interactive relationship between energy efficiency and environmental efficiency, promoting the green transition through feedback loops. However, this impact varies depending on specific measures, with energy efficiency mainly affecting environmental efficiency. When dynamic effects are introduced, path dependency affects both resource efficiency measures. Green technology has different impacts on energy and environmental efficiency, with a rebound effect. Green taxes only promote the green transition in terms of energy efficiency but hinder it in terms of environmental efficiency.
In summary, this paper proposes a new conceptual framework aimed at comprehensively analyzing resource efficiency measures and their interactions, filling a gap in existing research.