Ethnic-collective action, intergroup competition and social networks : Formation of ethnic-trade guilds

R. T. Tsukashima
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870701491846
2007-08-01
Abstract:Abstract This inquiry examines the conditions under which ethnicity gives rise to more stable forms of collective action such as ethnic-trade guilds. Derived from competition and enclave theory it tests the hypothesis that ethnic-trade guilds surface in response to: (a) intergroup competition; (b) shared judgement over the fairness of the exigent competition; and (c) the organizing capacity of ethnic networks. Supporting evidence rests on the mobilizing efforts of Japanese Americans in the immigrant-based niche of contract gardening and the new sentinels of this niche, Latino Americans. Two divergent patterns of intergroup competition are revealed: exclusion (marginalized) and inclusion (compelled incorporation). Both stem from competing groups over conflicting goals. Two additional expectations are confirmed – that inequity of intergroup competition facilitates the collective action process; and that ethnic networks operate as social conduits through which actors are mobilized.
Sociology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?