The contribution of Dutch municipalities to stimulate smoke-free outdoor sports clubs: a qualitative study

Rixt A Smit,Andrea D Rozema,Ien A M van de Goor,Anton E Kunst

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/heapro/daae011

2024-02-01

Health Promotion International

Abstract:Abstract Local governments may play a key role in making outdoor sports clubs smoke free. This study aims to assess the activities, motives, challenges and strategies of Dutch municipalities regarding stimulating outdoor sports clubs to become smoke free. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 19 policy officers of different municipalities in the Netherlands. The included municipalities varied in terms of region, population size and degree of urbanization. Data were analyzed using content analysis. Municipalities stimulated sports clubs to become smoke free by providing information and support and, to a lesser extent, by using financial incentives. Motives of municipalities varied from facilitating a healthy living environment for youth, responding to denormalization of smoking and aligning with goals formulated in national prevention policy. Policy officers faced several challenges, including limited capacity and funds, a reluctance to interfere with sports clubs and little support within the municipal organization. These challenges were addressed by employing various strategies such as embedding smoke-free sports in a broader preventive policy, setting a good example by creating outdoor smoke-free areas around municipal buildings, and collaborating with stakeholders in the municipality to join forces in realizing smoke-free sports clubs. Municipalities demonstrated evident motivation to contribute to a smoke-free sports environment. Currently, most municipalities fulfil an informative and supportive role, while some municipalities still explore their role and position in relation to supporting sports clubs to become smoke free. Other municipalities have established, according to them, effective strategies.

public, environmental & occupational health,health policy & services

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the role, activities, motivations, challenges, and strategies of Dutch municipal governments in promoting smoke-free outdoor sports clubs. Specifically, the study aims to assess the activities, motivations, challenges, and coping strategies of various Dutch municipal governments in encouraging outdoor sports clubs to achieve a smoke-free environment.

### Research Background
In recent years, many countries have been committed to achieving a "smoke-free generation," where smoking rates drop to 5% or below. This includes preventing adolescents from starting to smoke and protecting them from the harms of secondhand smoke. The implementation of smoke-free policies (SFPs) has expanded from indoor public places to outdoor areas, particularly to protect children's health and development. In the Netherlands, the National Prevention Agreement (NPA) has introduced new national policy measures, such as increasing tobacco taxes and banning smoking on school premises, and encourages local governments to support the creation of smoke-free environments through various measures.

### Research Purpose
The main purpose of this study is to assess the activities, motivations, challenges, and strategies of Dutch municipal governments in promoting smoke-free environments in outdoor sports clubs. The study collected data from 19 municipal policy officers from different regions through semi-structured interviews and analyzed their roles and impacts in this process.

### Main Findings
1. **Activities**:
- Municipal governments mainly encourage sports clubs to achieve smoke-free environments by providing information and support. These activities include distributing newsletters, organizing inspiration meetings, and workshops.
- A few municipal governments also use financial incentives, such as providing subsidies, to help sports clubs achieve smoke-free environments.

2. **Motivations**:
- Municipal governments feel responsible for creating a healthy growth environment for adolescents, especially in places where children are frequently active, such as sports clubs.
- Social attitudes towards smoking are gradually changing, and the national smoke-free movement has increased public support for smoke-free environments.
- The National Prevention Agreement requires local governments to commit to implementing specific prevention policies to achieve the goal of a smoke-free generation by 2040.
- Some municipal governments are inspired by the policies of other municipalities and do not want to fall behind.

3. **Challenges**:
- Limited resources and funding restrict the actions of municipal governments.
- Municipal governments are cautious about intervening in sports clubs, fearing that excessive interference may lead to volunteer loss and resistance.
- There is insufficient support within municipal governments for achieving smoke-free sports environments, especially when relevant officials do not support it.

4. **Strategies**:
- Municipal governments set a good example by establishing smoke-free zones around municipal buildings.
- Incorporating smoke-free sports clubs into broader prevention policies to increase internal support.
- Collaborating with multiple stakeholders within the municipality to jointly promote the realization of smoke-free environments.

### Conclusion
Despite the numerous challenges faced by Dutch municipal governments in promoting smoke-free outdoor sports clubs, they still demonstrate strong motivation and have adopted a series of effective strategies. These strategies not only help overcome resource and funding limitations but also enhance the influence and credibility of municipal governments in this field.